It's not overkill. Just turn them down. I run 2 photon 50's on my 60×30×21. Actual depth is 19".
2 50's would be considered overkill but I wanted a nice even blanket of par across my scape. With 2 I get that and can adjust power if the system demands it. 3 or4 uv/v bars give a nice blanket of uv/v across the system.
Your 18" wide system only needs 1 Meridian 35 for complete coverage or a used photon 48. Add a couple of uv/v bars for added color and par.
Also like I said before 3 xr15''s would be a good match in a system that's 18" wide by 16" tall.
Remember that 16" is only going to be 13" from the surface to the bottom.
Anyway just some more food for thought as lighting questions will give you many choices.
My 150 is 10 months old.