Should I be upset or complain?

Yeah there is no yellow whatsoever, so this is what upset me a bit that their title specifies its a yellow mushroom.
As someone that’s been in business for going on two decades, it’s insane that a vendor that depends on the online world would die on a hill like this. We’re talking a two inch frag that’s probably over inflated 200% in price markup and your answer to a product that doesn’t meet a customer‘s expectations is, sorry you’re lighting must be off, we don’t know what else to tell you.

Everybody that will find this thread at some point it will put doubt in a potential buyers mind which could cost them potentially X amount of sales versus maybe $100 of making something right for a customer. Even if this is a random incident, it is even more of a reason to correct it rather than let it ride. It shouldn’t matter even if you have an unhappy customer that is dead wrong, as a business at minimum you should at least try to meet halfway in some kind of resolution for both parties. That’s just basic business 101. But you bought it, it’s yours, get better lights, is nuts, especially in today’s world when you’re an online vendor like this, and the online world is your consumer base.

Even if you don’t wanna refund the coral, then give OP back half his money, send him a different coral/corals of a cheaper variety to compensate for the disappointment, give OP a gift certificate for $100 for his next purchase. There is a 1000 ways to go about this but you’re basically telling OP he’s the problem, or his setup is the problem, that your product isn’t the COLOR YOU SOLD AS ADVERTISED when he got it. If this was a $30 frag I’d just say fine you’re full of it, thing has no yellow and move on.

It is about accountability and customer service (this exact situation is a prime example of dead/bad customer service). At worst that coral coulda arrived 7 different shades of a variation of yellow and so be it, I’d tell OP yellow can vary from pictures. But instead it’s EXPENSIVE AND GREEN and the vendor basically publicly said, they were sorry that mentioning “yellow” might have caused some confusion, and can be very subjective.
So basically what you’re saying is you wanna take zero accountability for the product and how you listed or represented it?? Excellent. Looks to me as you better start putting disclaimers all over your product listings because all of it could be interpreted however one may see fit and you as a company aren’t even sure what the difference between yellow and green are as it’s all subjective and don’t really know what you’re selling or listing. Perfect. Thanks for the bid of confidence. That’s the formula for repeat business if I’ve ever seen it in action
 
I use ai prime HD. In this picture uv and blues 100% and cool white at 20%
Is there a way for you to increase the cool blue and decrease the royal?
I don't know if those mushrooms have true yellow fluorescent proteins or it looks that way through a combination.
 
Is there a way for you to increase the cool blue and decrease the royal?
I don't know if those mushrooms have true yellow fluorescent proteins or it looks that way through a combination.
I’m familiar with jawbreakers, shrooms and corals of all types. This isn’t a lighting issue. It’s a green shroom that can appear bright green.

The fact they put yellow in the title is the issue. It’s not a yellow coral so it’s misleading.
 
1000013107.jpg


Here's a yellow coral and a green coral next to each other since some people in this thread can't tell the two apart and blame lighting. There's not a spec of yellow on that shroom under any light except Photoshop.
 
@ArtofReefing
Here ya go

I undid the editing

Here is
Listing photo
Listing photo with editing removed
Your photo

The unedited photo matches your photo

The edits made were tint, warmth, highlights

And magically, the yellow coral becomes it’s true self
D607E9A6-3278-4A48-B50A-50D519E7F10D.jpeg
 
Anyhow I have seen yellow red splatter mushrooms. Here’s a photo of a small one in 6500K, 8000K, 20000K lighting taken with an iPhone 13 without any correction.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8799.jpeg
    IMG_8799.jpeg
    162.6 KB · Views: 56
  • IMG_8800.jpeg
    IMG_8800.jpeg
    182.9 KB · Views: 50
  • IMG_8803.jpeg
    IMG_8803.jpeg
    114.9 KB · Views: 73
@ArtofReefing
Here ya go

I undid the editing

Here is
Listing photo
Listing photo with editing removed
Your photo

The unedited photo matches your photo

The edits made were tint, warmth, highlights

And magically, the yellow coral becomes it’s true self
D607E9A6-3278-4A48-B50A-50D519E7F10D.jpeg
That's how it should have been listing from the beginning. Thanks for that comparison @VintageReefer
 
Hey guys just an update. Queen City Corals offered to give me a full refund if I send the coral back to them. They would provide a shipping label for me. I asked them if they would consider refunding me 30% and I would keep the mushroom for what it is. They ended up refunding me 50% of the cost at their own will. I'm glad they were able to make things right. I still think they should reconsider how they advertise their corals moving forward to avoid this from happening again. I believe that if it wasn't for the reef2reef community blowing this up I wouldn't have gotten any type of refund or compensation at all. So thank you guys for your help and support.
Screenshot_20250301-152109_Gmail.jpg
Screenshot_20250301-151831_Gmail.jpg
 
Hey guys just an update. Queen City Corals offered to give me a full refund if I send the coral back to them. They would provide a shipping label for me. I asked them if they would consider refunding me 30% and I would keep the mushroom for what it is. They ended up refunding me 50% of the cost at their own will. I'm glad they were able to make things right. I still think they should reconsider how they advertise their corals moving forward to avoid this from happening again. I believe that if it wasn't for the reef2reef community blowing this up I wouldn't have gotten any type of refund or compensation at all. So thank you guys for your help and support.
Screenshot_20250301-152109_Gmail.jpg
Screenshot_20250301-151831_Gmail.jpg
Glad a resolution was agreed upon and they exceeded your request.
 
right on! I was getting nervous how long it would go on I like QCC they have some good stuff.

you'll never see a sponsor held to account like this
 
It's magic my green elegance turned yellow it only took several layers of camera filtering and changing the tone labout 3 layers . But it's just the lighting...

1000002074.jpg
1000002514.jpg
Nice!
How much for the yellow one? I already have a green one.
 
This has scared me away from ever buying online.

Reef Chasers does online but after all the photoshopped images or people being upset. I just kept my cart full. Then I realized they were a 2 hour drive. So I went in there to Reef Chasers and their photos and corals look identical. There is some difference when I get them home but it’s so minor you have to really be looking to see it.

I am such a noob and I couldn’t tell you the difference between a pixel or a pixy stick.

I am simple human and don’t want to adjust 30 variables to make a coral match a color or pop.

Hell, if I could get the blue out of the picture I take, when I need help identifying a problem I would be over the moon. this post motivated me to buy one of them phone lens things.

I am glad OP got some consideration for the massive misrepresentation.

I am also thankful I found R2R, and can learn enough to at least know “what not to do” enough so I won’t blow a gasket getting something that is yellow but is actually just green.
 
This has scared me away from ever buying online.

Reef Chasers does online but after all the photoshopped images or people being upset. I just kept my cart full. Then I realized they were a 2 hour drive. So I went in there to Reef Chasers and their photos and corals look identical. There is some difference when I get them home but it’s so minor you have to really be looking to see it.

I am such a noob and I couldn’t tell you the difference between a pixel or a pixy stick.

I am simple human and don’t want to adjust 30 variables to make a coral match a color or pop.

Hell, if I could get the blue out of the picture I take, when I need help identifying a problem I would be over the moon. this post motivated me to buy one of them phone lens things.

I am glad OP got some consideration for the massive misrepresentation.

I am also thankful I found R2R, and can learn enough to at least know “what not to do” enough so I won’t blow a gasket getting something that is yellow but is actually just green.
Buy from a few vendors and you’ll quickly learn whose pics are accurate and whose are drastically edited…and who you’ll be a repeat customer with
 
Aside from all the conversations on color, photographing and what was expected.

I kind of like the Green/Red jawbreaker...it is different from the Red/Orange and Green stripes.

So, in the end it might be a very cool piece and if you get it to reproduce..it may become a hot seller as well.
Grinch Jawbreaker
 
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.

TOP 10 Trending Threads

ARE YOU READY TO CONFESS TO CRAZIEST, DUMBEST, FUNNIEST THING YOU’VE EVER DONE IN REEFING?

  • Yeah, I'll confess! (Share your story in the comments!)

    Votes: 74 54.8%
  • Nah, I'll keep mine a secret...(Don't be like that, share with the class!)

    Votes: 61 45.2%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new