very upset about the help

[shyann009]

very disappointed about the help you guys claim to give. i tried to help help about my pallies and zoas. but no help at all. very dissatisfied

 

[PeterC99]

very disappointed about the help you guys claim to give. i tried to help help about my pallies and zoas. but no help at all. very dissatisfied

What’s the problem?

 

[CubsFan]

Here’s a link to the post. https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/pallies-dying-please-help.833884/#post-9003187 Any ammonia in the system is not going to end well. Did something recently die in the tank? Is your tank new? If you don’t finish the nitrogen cycle, you should not be adding live animals.

 

[Travv26]

I just looked back at your first post. Not trying to be harsh or mean, you just aren’t providing enough information for anyone to really help you out.

More information is always better and I’d like to help out if I’m able to as well as many more members would providing a story/information. I rather read a whole bunch of information stating everything about your tank and what had lead up to this. Trust me some of the most overlooked simple things could be the worst problems and figuring out what those changes you have done to the tank and or things that are leading up to the problems you are noticing may help out figuring out how to fix the situation

Recovering from a tank crash killing about 80% of my sps sticks can vouch for this all things help, probably would have never figured out my issue even after I stated all tank parameters from icp test showing no problems. Was it till after talking about my previous maintenance/water change did we come down to being a bacterial/dead bacterial issue

 

[Chefwheredyougo]

Just read your first post... pretty much what I got from it is you still have detectable ammonia, no nitrite, no nitrates (haven't completed your cycle), your parameters are pretty unstable, your adding a new light (again instability), you've added an anemone already, and just assuming here, you don't test the big 3.

To help you, get your parameters stable and complete your cycle before you start throwing animals that can and will die, and possibly harm yourself and/or your family into your tank. Get your nutrients up a bit for all 3 of the inhabitants you mentioned in your first post.
Check all of your water parameters, ensure there's no contaminants like aerosols sprayed near the tank, make sure there's nothing munching or otherwise bothering them. Return with whatever information you've gathered.



Btw, do you have any fish CUC or anything besides the 3 you've mentioned?

 

[MaxTremors]

very disappointed about the help you guys claim to give. i tried to help help about my pallies and zoas. but no help at all. very dissatisfied.

You never followed up or provided any of the information asked for. If you want help, you have to be willing to be proactive in the process. The only thing I can tell you from the info you provided is that a 4° temperature swing throughout the day is not good, and your salinity not being stable isn’t good either (1.025-1.027 is kind of a big swing to be bouncing back and forth, your salinity should be 1.026, if you can’t maintain it by either doing daily top-offs or limiting evaporation, get an ATO). If those two parameters which are the easiest to get stable are swinging so drastically, I can only imagine what your other parameters are doing. But we don’t know, because you never followed up or provided the information asked for. If there’s anyone you should be disappointed in, it’s yourself.

 

[A2dahlberg]

I didn't even see this post, sorry. RL in the way of everything.
Lets start at tank size?
Water parameters?
Light type and duration?
Filtration?
and anything else I might have forgot to ask?

 

[revhtree]

Relocated here: https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/pallies-dying-please-help.833884/