40 breeder build/stocking

  • Thread starter Thread starter solar
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
A 40 is not good for any tang as youve alrdy experienced with the powder brown. Clown tangs especially are the most agressive tangs along with sohal tangs. Maybe a kole tang but even then it needs a bigger tank like 75g
 
Ty everyone for the advice, Got my takn stablilized finally! lets see if it stay that way!

sg 1.025
ph 8.2
mag 1300
calcium 480
alk 10
I havent seen a worm in days :D
Still plan on dipping them in 3 more days again.
the lime acro totally stn minus the 2 frags I cut way high to try to avoid them stn or rtn w/e it was.
How can someone keep tangs in a cube but not a long tank I don't understand..
Not saying you guys are wrong. Just a question.
Here are some shots
IMAG0705.jpg
pinger_1444925686.jpg
pinger_1444918730.jpg
IMAG0703.jpg
 
For fish like tangs its about swimming area. If u had a 300g tank full of rock the tang wouldnt be happy either.
No im saying people with 60 galon cubes and such, I have been reading alot of build threads and most have a tang or 2 in them.
The only long term experience I have with tangs is a yellow tang I had for years in a 50 gallon way back when.
 
Dude, just because someone else does something it doesn't make it right or best for the inhabitants. If it did, I would have a shark in my 110.
 
Dude, just because someone else does something it doesn't make it right or best for the inhabitants. If it did, I would have a shark in my 110.
Aww then youd mess up all your pretty corals.

I understand all that, all im asking is, how is a cube better for tangs than a long tank?
 
Aww then youd mess up all your pretty corals.

I understand all that, all im asking is, how is a cube better for tangs than a long tank?

Its not. Neither are 2' tall tanks for that matter. Tangs and big fish need lots of space. Basically we have them all in jail cells. Sure you can survive but doesnt mean your happy.
 
Its not. Neither are 2' tall tanks for that matter. Tangs and big fish need lots of space. Basically we have them all in jail cells. Sure you can survive but doesnt mean your happy.
Ah ok ty for explaining that for me. IM GOOING TO BE A DADDY!!!!!!!! WOHOOOOOOO
 
Congrats on becoming a father. There's nothing in the world like it!

Let me jump in on a bit of a different note on the Clown tang from a different angle. This particular tang is an "Expert Only" fish on any site you see it. The reason it need lots of swimming room is for and highly oxygenated water with lots of flow. That's why it's recommended a MINUMUM of a 6 foot tank is suggested. This is not a blanket statement for all tangs from a species/genus level. You pointed that out with the Yellow. The Zebrasoma gill structure doesn't require as much constant swimming as the Acanthurus family. The clown tank at 2" won't be happy, and (even though I really don't wish this) won't survive for long in such a short swimming space due to lack of oxygenated water.

So, I do wish you the best of luck with the tang, please lmk before you put him in a Tupperware container cuz he's killing things in your tang. As gemoney said, you picked one of the most aggressive tangs available in the hobby. Some are lobbying to remove the clown from being available at all for the reasons above leading to the high death rate in captivity.
 
Congrats on becoming a father. There's nothing in the world like it!

Let me jump in on a bit of a different note on the Clown tang from a different angle. This particular tang is an "Expert Only" fish on any site you see it. The reason it need lots of swimming room is for and highly oxygenated water with lots of flow. That's why it's recommended a MINUMUM of a 6 foot tank is suggested. This is not a blanket statement for all tangs from a species/genus level. You pointed that out with the Yellow. The Zebrasoma gill structure doesn't require as much constant swimming as the Acanthurus family. The clown tank at 2" won't be happy, and (even though I really don't wish this) won't survive for long in such a short swimming space due to lack of oxygenated water.

So, I do wish you the best of luck with the tang, please lmk before you put him in a Tupperware container cuz he's killing things in your tang. As gemoney said, you picked one of the most aggressive tangs available in the hobby. Some are lobbying to remove the clown from being available at all for the reasons above leading to the high death rate in captivity.
Apprecite the kind words, I left him where I found him.
 
So you really are going to be a father? I was waiting for a comment like "my clowns just laid a bunch of eggs" or something on the order...

Congrats Phil!
 
So you really are going to be a father? I was waiting for a comment like "my clowns just laid a bunch of eggs" or something on the order...

Congrats Phil!

Yup I'm going to be having a actual baby. And Ty!!!

Sent Via the R2R Forum APP
 
Soo I got a skunk cleaner shrimp today and my anthias keep going up to him/her to get cleaned and the shrimp wants no part of it... My luck Is this normal? The anthias is like CLEAN ME skunk is like w/e go away lol...
IMAG0742.jpg
 
Give the shrimp a cpl days he should start cleaning fairly fast but generally not.right away.
Ty my anthias is soo funny he swims away to come right back in the shrimps face and the shrimp just stays in one place this has been going on for about 5 hours now lol. Its amuzing<-- "probably spelled wrong im kinda buzzed" in itself.

Also note that in my old tank way back when, my cleaner shrimp used to ride my yellow tang like he was a horse it was helarious.
 
Last edited:

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 2.9%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 4 11.8%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 25 73.5%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 4 11.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new