CoralRX worth buying?

[Rickyrooz]

I saw the review on CoralRx at AdvancedAquarist.com. I'm not convinced that it works for everything after looking at Ed Reef's tank thread. It doesn't seem to work on montipora eating nudibranches. Has anyone used this product and have good/bad things to say about it?

Advanced Aquarist (studying conducted on flatworms, not acropora eating flatworms)
Advanced Aquarist's Online Magazine - Feature Article: Evaluation of Chemical Eradication Methods of Acoels (Acoelomorpha) From Marine Aquaria

Ed Reef's
Ed Reef's Shallow Crest Inspired ART - Page 18 - Reef Central Online Community
Ed Reef's Shallow Crest Inspired ART - Page 18 - Reef Central Online Community

CoralRx
Coral Rx - Promotes Healthy Corals

 

[benny z]

i use it. and i learned the hard way that it doesn't kill redbugs. after looking on their website after the fact, i did see a little note "may not be effective against the treatement of acropora redbugs".

i use it mostly because it definitely kills aefw's...and many other things.

 

[Rickyrooz]

Is it any better than TLF ReVive?

 

[benny z]

hard to say. they both smell the same...like pine sol!

 

[saltyfishguy]

Is it any better than TLF ReVive?

I talked with Phillip Root about this over a year ago and while I do not remeber the entire conversation the two are similar with the coral rx being more concentrated and using different binders. Whether that means one is better than the othe I can not say but I do know it is effective against aefw

 

[JR's Reef]

I talked with Phillip Root about this over a year ago and while I do not remeber the entire conversation the two are similar with the coral rx being more concentrated and using different binders. Whether that means one is better than the othe I can not say but I do know it is effective against aefw

Phillip use to be local to me. We got to try it before and after the finally product. I will say it works very well but dont kill red bugs. I dont think it kills the eggs of ME nudis or the eggs of AEFW but does kill the adults. Yes the CoralRX is more concentrated.

 

[knockout]

any more info from users?

 

[Douglam]

i have to say it is my favorite dip so far. used to use revive, and now im using coral RX because it kills AEFW. I on the other hand though did have luck using it on redbugs. i had a yellow coraliana cover in redbugs and i dipped it and saw no more red bugs....and this is a coral that is very easy to see them on. have no seen them on it since.