Now the pump go between 500-699.99 and ,1000-1400 is a hard pill to swallow knowing what I now about the seals .
Yeah, I see prices around $500 on a quick search, by no means "cheap"
per se.
For comparison, I think getting 5 years out of the DCP will be doing pretty good. $225/(5*365)=$0.12 a day. So in the long run, my prediction is that they may actually cost double....plus they're fairly worse for the environment disposal-wise since the whole pump likely becomes waste with each cycle.
Oh I definitely got my money worth out of them but also lost more then the pumps where worth when the sealed gave out at once . Now the pump go between 500-699.99 and ,1000-1400 is a hard pill to swallow knowing what I now about the seals .Dont get me wrong reeflo pumps are very good at what they do . But I can get two of these pumps for less then one of the reeflo .
I ordered a kill a watt meter it says it will be here on the 29th
You definitely have to account for that. Maybe it could be prevented in the future somehow though....maybe altering the installation a bit or whatever since detection alone didn't seem to prevent the damage.
Circumstances can result in a cracked pump housing, which can lead to electricity and corrosion getting into the tank, which is something that can't happen with an external pump. While probably unlikely, it's worth pointing out that I'm not just being theoretical, I'm referring to threads on here – it does happen. (Failure modes vary and it might be little better these days than in the past, but swelling and cracking have always been an issue with cheaper/off brand submersible pumps in the hobby.)
Certainly one advantage of a submersible pump is that a pump breakdown will never (automatically) amount to a flood – and worrying about floods might be the main reason I use submersibles, if I'm honest. ;)
Since I'm still in decision mode on this for a system in planning, BTW, why not an Iwaki/Panworld/Little Giant style pump? Seems like that design might be the best of both worlds – no seals to give out + mag drive reliability + external pump rebuild-ability.
P.S. Also curious how you characterize the noise levels of both pumps once you have the new one in place.