I don't think you could define a Reef Tank as one entity. You have basically fish and corals.
I believe success is of those things live as long as their perceived natural lifespan.
With fish that is easy and if even one person can keep a Royal Gramma for 15 years, we know that that species can live at "least" that long. I think the oldest person was like 117 or something like that but we know we can't live longer.
So if for instance we keep a Royal Gramma for five years, that is a dismal failure
(I do not know the life span of a Royal Gramma, I just picked that as an example)
Corals are different because they don't have a lifespan and should live forever as most of them keep reproducing and growing on top of their parents.
Corals are the oldest organisms on Earth as far as I know. (not counting Betty White, who I love)
I think I have achieved success with fish as my fish almost all die of old age, but I failed miserably with corals. Most of my corals are less then 10 years old but my tank is a lot older.
Especially LPS which I can get to grow very large, then in a number of years they shrink which is not a success at all.