I’ve posted this other places, but I’ll post here too. These are the reasons I prefer halides. If my tank were smaller I 100% would have a halide/T5 hybrid. But my setup with canopy is not conducive to T5s.
tank is 6’ x 3’ x 27” deep. Peninsula dividing kitchen/dining and the area. Stand is 42” tall and full canopy going basically to ceiling. The canopy has 3 doors on each side and doors on ends. So changing a 6’ bulb would be tough with one person.
reasons why I prefer halides for my setup:
1. My house stays 68-75 year round. The halides provide heat stability so during the day my heaters do not turn on and my temp is stable. No chiller necessary.
2. I’ve had diodes break on expensive LED fixtures and I don’t want to replace expensive units. I prefer changing my halide bulbs every 18months rather than replacing whole units and figuring out new units.
3. I strongly prefer the spectrum and color of a 14k bulb over anything my LEDs produce. Setting my Mitras LX7 to 14k just doesn’t have the depth of that makes sense.
4. for my tank width, 36”, a halide reflector gives me much better spread than the LED units. I find I need basically twice as many LED units as the manufacturer recommends.
i also have LEDs on my setup. I use 3 mitras LX7 during the hours my halides are off. They provide ramping up and ramping down for my viewing when I’m home. The halides are running 4hrs per day at the moment
If there ever comes a time where halides are at risk of disappearing, I will simply load up on 30yrs worth of bulbs (40 bulbs at $60/bulb) which is only $2400. Less than I spent on my LEDs.
And I don’t hate LEDs at all they definitely serve a purpose. I have a coral QT next to my DT that uses Two kessils. I’ll likely swap them for mitras or possibly the SKY. (I own 5 mitras and 6 kessil a360).
Hopefully this post will help show new reefers that halides absolutely have benefits over LEDs. I’m not saying they are better in all circumstances but certainly better in my situation.
tank is 6’ x 3’ x 27” deep. Peninsula dividing kitchen/dining and the area. Stand is 42” tall and full canopy going basically to ceiling. The canopy has 3 doors on each side and doors on ends. So changing a 6’ bulb would be tough with one person.
reasons why I prefer halides for my setup:
1. My house stays 68-75 year round. The halides provide heat stability so during the day my heaters do not turn on and my temp is stable. No chiller necessary.
2. I’ve had diodes break on expensive LED fixtures and I don’t want to replace expensive units. I prefer changing my halide bulbs every 18months rather than replacing whole units and figuring out new units.
3. I strongly prefer the spectrum and color of a 14k bulb over anything my LEDs produce. Setting my Mitras LX7 to 14k just doesn’t have the depth of that makes sense.
4. for my tank width, 36”, a halide reflector gives me much better spread than the LED units. I find I need basically twice as many LED units as the manufacturer recommends.
i also have LEDs on my setup. I use 3 mitras LX7 during the hours my halides are off. They provide ramping up and ramping down for my viewing when I’m home. The halides are running 4hrs per day at the moment
If there ever comes a time where halides are at risk of disappearing, I will simply load up on 30yrs worth of bulbs (40 bulbs at $60/bulb) which is only $2400. Less than I spent on my LEDs.
And I don’t hate LEDs at all they definitely serve a purpose. I have a coral QT next to my DT that uses Two kessils. I’ll likely swap them for mitras or possibly the SKY. (I own 5 mitras and 6 kessil a360).
Hopefully this post will help show new reefers that halides absolutely have benefits over LEDs. I’m not saying they are better in all circumstances but certainly better in my situation.