Pistol Shrimp - Bad Neighbor or Wrongfully Accused?

Beaker1811

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 13, 2021
Messages
23
Reaction score
63
Location
Arkansas
I am wanting to do a YWG/pistol shrimp combo, but have read a few stories of pistol shrimp accidentally killing fish (something about being a blind man running around with a loaded gun) and I have some fish that I am definitely not willing to sacrifice on the pistol shrimp altar. My question is, are these stories more urban legend or is this a real issue I need to be concerned with before moving forward? TIA!
 
Maxout

iMi

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 13, 2021
Messages
491
Reaction score
828
Location
Chicago, IL
I don't believe they are capable of killing fish. I have a pair and would caution you on another issues -- the mess they make. If you like to keep corals in the sand bed or have smaller rocks or even have corals growing close to the sand, be ready for them to get buried from time to time. They seem to "re-decorate" a lot.
 
Fritz

Snuffy The Seal

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 10, 2016
Messages
33
Reaction score
21
Location
Chicago
I am wanting to do a YWG/pistol shrimp combo, but have read a few stories of pistol shrimp accidentally killing fish (something about being a blind man running around with a loaded gun) and I have some fish that I am definitely not willing to sacrifice on the pistol shrimp altar. My question is, are these stories more urban legend or is this a real issue I need to be concerned with before moving forward? TIA!
Had my pistol shrimp kill hermits before, never fish though. Pretty peaceful inverts.
 

Micro-Reefs Aquarium

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 28, 2021
Messages
298
Reaction score
205
Location
United States
I don't mean to resurrect this thread, but I inherited a hitch hiker pistol shrimp and it didn't pair up with a Yasha. For weeks the yasha just avoided the shrimp. Now, the yasha is gone and I just added 4 new gobies to the 12 gallon tank. Two green banded gobies, one green gumdrop goby, and one stripped goby.

I tried to catch the pistol shrimp before I relocated the aquarium, but he hid inside the rock and I JUST DIDN'T HAVE THE HEART TO LET THE ROCK STAY OUT OF THE WATER TOO LONG.

The shrimp makes clicking sounds in the night, so I know it is taking out my small blue legged hermit crabs, several are missing already.

The shrimp is small but has that hammer claw that clicks, so I am worried that it will kill the 4 new fish I just added. Does anyone have experience with small gobies getting eaten by the pistol shrimp?
 

Jekyl

GSP is the devil and clowns are bad pets
View Badges
Joined
Jan 15, 2019
Messages
5,342
Reaction score
8,859
Location
Michigan
I don't mean to resurrect this thread, but I inherited a hitch hiker pistol shrimp and it didn't pair up with a Yasha. For weeks the yasha just avoided the shrimp. Now, the yasha is gone and I just added 4 new gobies to the 12 gallon tank. Two green banded gobies, one green gumdrop goby, and one stripped goby.

I tried to catch the pistol shrimp before I relocated the aquarium, but he hid inside the rock and I JUST DIDN'T HAVE THE HEART TO LET THE ROCK STAY OUT OF THE WATER TOO LONG.

The shrimp makes clicking sounds in the night, so I know it is taking out my small blue legged hermit crabs, several are missing already.

The shrimp is small but has that hammer claw that clicks, so I am worried that it will kill the 4 new fish I just added. Does anyone have experience with small gobies getting eaten by the pistol shrimp?
I've had pistol shrimp for years and haven't attributed a single death to them.
 
Champion Lighting & Supply

Micro-Reefs Aquarium

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 28, 2021
Messages
298
Reaction score
205
Location
United States
I've had pistol shrimp for years and haven't attributed a single death to them.
That is good news, since I have had the same luck with the candy cane pistol paired with yasha in the past. However, this small pistol shrimp is not a candy cane, he is small like them but a different color, golden color, and the Yasha I purchased and placed in avoids him, so I know it was not the symbiotic pair.

However, the Yasha which was tank raised purchased is gone and I suspect the shrimp but no proof.

I just hope that he keeps to the small hermit crabs, I can get him those not a problem, but not my new 4 fish that I just placed into the system.
 

RickNavyDad

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 16, 2021
Messages
21
Reaction score
7
Location
Palm Springs
That is good news, since I have had the same luck with the candy cane pistol paired with yasha in the past. However, this small pistol shrimp is not a candy cane, he is small like them but a different color, golden color, and the Yasha I purchased and placed in avoids him, so I know it was not the symbiotic pair.

However, the Yasha which was tank raised purchased is gone and I suspect the shrimp but no proof.

I just hope that he keeps to the small hermit crabs, I can get him those not a problem, but not my new 4 fish that I just placed into the system.
I had a candy cane and a Wheeler's gobie. They didn't pair and the gobie died. I suspect it wasn't eating well. I just added a new gobie, to be honest not even sure what it is, but it's purdy. The new gobie and shrimp paired instantly, and the shrimp is really active now.
 

Trouble1375

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 24, 2019
Messages
329
Reaction score
277
Location
Warren
Had a 2" Tiger Pistol - responsible for the death of 3 very small talbot damsels - the carcasses were in his cave that he shared with the wide barred shrimp Goby. The pistol has lost the battle though - my Melanurus pair find shrimp quite tasty and we can only keep shrimp in our sump now.
 

Sharkbait19

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 13, 2020
Messages
3,613
Reaction score
3,774
Location
New Jersey
I don't mean to resurrect this thread, but I inherited a hitch hiker pistol shrimp and it didn't pair up with a Yasha. For weeks the yasha just avoided the shrimp. Now, the yasha is gone and I just added 4 new gobies to the 12 gallon tank. Two green banded gobies, one green gumdrop goby, and one stripped goby.

I tried to catch the pistol shrimp before I relocated the aquarium, but he hid inside the rock and I JUST DIDN'T HAVE THE HEART TO LET THE ROCK STAY OUT OF THE WATER TOO LONG.

The shrimp makes clicking sounds in the night, so I know it is taking out my small blue legged hermit crabs, several are missing already.

The shrimp is small but has that hammer claw that clicks, so I am worried that it will kill the 4 new fish I just added. Does anyone have experience with small gobies getting eaten by the pistol shrimp?
Likely one of the non-symbiotic species.
 
First Choice

Have you ever had a reef tank with no sump and how did it go?

  • YES and it was just fine

    Votes: 223 59.0%
  • YES but it was difficult

    Votes: 69 18.3%
  • NO

    Votes: 76 20.1%
  • Other (please explain)

    Votes: 10 2.6%
Top