Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Very much agreed with Tampa Bay. I just purchased the “package” and it is absolutely wonderful. Full of life. Pricey, but well worth it. Richard who runs it is cool to work with and believes in a simple approach with great results.I don’t have any sort of filter sock (or filter paper) in my sump and I don’t miss it a bit. It is only one more thing to take care of and in my opinion doesn’t really add that much value. My water is crystal clear without anything. For nutrient uptake, I do have a refugium that grows Chaeto like crazy and an oversized skimmer. I feed fairly heavy and don’t worry too much about it. My tank is coming up on two years and I am just now able to grow SPS with some success. Stability is more the key here. I try to automate as much as possible to keep things consistent. However don’t get too caught up in gadgets. Keep it as simple as possible. Automate only when needed.
In my opinion, start with all live rock and a strong clean up crew. Tampa Bay Saltwater has incredible man made rock that they dumped in the ocean for a while. I have heard nothing but great things about their rock. Wishing I would have started with their rock. Expensive but well worth avoiding the headache of starting with dry.
A few of my opinions! Hope it helps.
I agree on many principles you mentioned. An undergravel filter, 2 powerheads and a heater and let the stocking beginInteresting thread all. I love following methods that seem unorthodox. There are more ways than one to running a reef tank. I first ran a SW tank 20 years ago when I was in my teens. I knew nothing. I kept a 100+ gallon tank with ocean rock, tangs, triggers and other things. I had no sump, no skimmer, just a HOB and knew nothing about anything. No fish deaths whatsoever. Never heard of ich, velvet or any of that. Water top offs with Hawaii tap water. Ocean water for WC.
Fast forward a few years, I see everyone runs GFO, huge skimmers (I use now), tons of reactors, QT with copper is commonplace, etc. I feel this hobby has turned into a money machine and a workhorse. Be what it is, I enjoy it but I’m still old school in a lot of ways.
I don’t think you have to dogmatically follow any method. Your time investment now, in 6 months, busy periods etc. will be the most important single factor for everything.
Before deciding what to do you should have an idea of what kind of tank you want to keep. It’s fine to make changes later but it will take more time.
If you’re the type of person who won’t resist adding “just one more fish” but also want to keep sps - you’ll probably going to end up with a more complex system than if you wanted to have an overstocked tank with soft or lps corals. My tanks have always been fairly high nutrient systems, overstocked by some standards, and I like sps - I use a rollermat (and several other nutrient export methods), it helps but it’s no silver bullet. I also keep a refugium and harvest algae weekly. There are very few absolutes in nature and this hobby so keep a healthy dose of skepticism and question statements like “must have to achieve x” in particular.
Best advice is to find someone who has a similar tank to what you would like and then try to replicate what they’re doing. There are some caveats to this, all people are prone to survivorship (success) bias. Even well intentioned people will often overlook a thing or two. In the end you’ll end up with what works for you which may or may not resemble any established method.
Thanks, appreciate the candid insights.
I’m reading that some reefers are struggling with refugiums as a primary/sole nutrient export pathway and more so from a nuisance algae perspective - both in the sump and display tank. Any experience or tips in this regard?
Did you have to walk uphill both ways to buy fish? Jk.No, it's not caveman style, it's trying to enlighten the young ones, reminding them how the hobby has advanced. Heee
UG filters? What year is it? I feel like most try to do to much to fast for a UG to keep up. That being said, it does hold a solid place in the filtration world...I agree on many principles you mentioned. An undergravel filter, 2 powerheads and a heater and let the stocking begin
Thanks, appreciate the candid insights.
I’m reading that some reefers are struggling with refugiums as a primary/sole nutrient export pathway and more so from a nuisance algae perspective - both in the sump and display tank. Any experience or tips in this regard?
Under Gravel = UGUG filters? What year is it? I feel like most try to do to much to fast for a UG to keep up. That being said, it does hold a solid place in the filtration world...
I am as old school as you can get. The day this hobby started I was standing on the dock waiting for them to open the nets. :cool:
Me and Noah picked through the living stuff and threw out the trilobites and Godzilla Larvae. I cycled my tank with Celacanths. No, they are not extinct. ;)
. With 30 minutes maintenance a week this tank maintains itself.

@Ross Petersen
Because you mentioned advanced degree in biochemistry, as a Marine Engineer and hobbiest of 48 years, I will address the degree. The average hobbiest, as influenced by vendors who target components in an EcoSystem that has evolved into a wonderfully complex interconnected & dependent ecosystem that is holistic in Nature, with crosstalk between bacteria, algae and coral.
Just Google Coral Holobiont
https://www.whoi.edu/fileserver.do?id=196446&pt=2&p=15756
When algae, bacteria and coral can adjust their dna expression in response to changing conditions hobbiest should not be surprised that treatments with chemicals doesn’t always produce expected results.
Let’s talk about your protein skimmer or foam fractionator. Ken Felderman articles at Advanced Aquaria on carbon dosing give much insight on the science.
I will simplify and paraphrase: skimmate is mostly bacteria. Bactetia are food for hungry mouths in a reef tank. Protein skimmers perform nutrient export. Considering that bacteria move nutrients from one tropic level to another, on the Natural Reef that amounts to more than 60 of food ingested by coral.
Google “microbial highway” to see what you are removing with a protein skimmer. To further illustrate the point, amino acids are produced when bacteria act on protein (food).
I will stop at this point. Good fortune on your journey into a marvelous hobby.
Thanks, and likewise.
I would hypothesize the window on reefkeeping that is to be opened in the coming years relates to microbial biodiversity. ‘You are what you eat’ is backed by strong microbiome research in humans... and surely some research in the marine biology world.
Things like tank collapses or old tank syndrome that occur when ICP tests are often stable is and indication that small life, bacteria, and viruses are at work.