There are a number of reasons for the struggle. One is not using a big enough refugium for the size of tank. Two is using a weak light source. Three is poorly choosing macro. I am a huge fan of a chaeto or dragons breath fuge (other algae can go asexual and cause problems. This used to be a major complaint before chaeto became all the rage). The last is that junk builds up in the chaeto. It can become a nutrient trap. Every water chance I shake the stuff off in the water change bucket to “rinse” it. Yes I loose some pods... but I have plenty.
I can not recommend a fuge enough! Great way to remove nutrients, add food to the tank, increase water volume, and increase pH at night. Pretty big wins all the way around. For myself I have found that the benefits have well outweighed the drawbacks. It should also be noted that I NO longer keep sand or substrate in my fuge. I just found it to be a HUGE pain to keep clean. I totally get the benefits of mud or a fine sand bed back there... but it was a pain and I have not found that I missed out on anything by removing it. I also keep water flow slow back there. I am debating adding little plastic baskets (think strawberry or tomato baskets) of rubble back there for pods, easy to shake clean, easy for sponges to grow in (providing you don’t remove them to shake them). Seen people do it. Love the idea... but have no personal experience.