I have a TDS meter between my membranes and the DI stage to know when the membranes are shot. I think they are a good investment. With 170 TDS coming in your TDS to the DI stage should be less then around 8.5, depending on your membrane's rejection rate. A lot of 100 GPD membranes are 95% so 8.5 in the output line. 170 in is not too bad so your resin should be lasting for hundreds of gallons. I'd check your source water for Chloramines and test the TDS out of your membranes. If they are both okay you may have gotten bad resin.