vodka dosing

  • Thread starter Thread starter beaslbob
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

beaslbob

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
May 11, 2009
Messages
4,086
Reaction score
956
Location
huntsville, al
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
As most of you already know I don't trust much of anything except plant life (macro algaes) to control nitrates.

From: Vodka dosing..DONT DO IT !!!! - Reef Central Online Community

above thread said:
Hi,

I'm new to this forum...but have been building my reef tank 100 Gallons for just over a year without any mishaps. My only issue is that despite regular water changes, aggressive skimming and so forth, I have been unable to reduce nitrates below 60. I decided after some research to try vodka dosing and followed this method "Vodka Dosing...Distilled!A Powerful Method for the Reduction of Nitrates and Phosphates within the Reef Aquaria
by Nathaniel A. Walton (Genetics) and Matt Bjornson (Stony_Corals)" http://reefkeeping.com/issues/2008-08/nftt/index.php

I followed this exactly as described for 5 days..... This morning, I found my yellow tang, chocolate tang, 5 x chromis, blue damsel, royal dotty and they were all dead. I am very upset, have had these fish for 10 months.

DO NOT VODKA DOSE YOUR TANK !!!!!

I suspected this kind of thing because you have to start with low values and slowly build up with the vodka method. A couple of years ago the club had a meeting at lucy's lagoon where they showed off and explained there "sugar orp" method of controlling nitrates. A few months later Lucy was fustrated because nitrates were higher then ever.

So what you guys think?


I think I'll continue being "old school". :sure:
 
Last edited:
He od'd his tank. Too much too fast of ANYTHING in a reef tank is no good.

Not saying vodka is a good idea or not, but only having a tank up for a year and probably being a newer reefer is never a good idea. Vodka dosing is something that should be researched for a long time so you fully understand the chemical makeup of a tank to prevent things like that from happening.
If he was watching his tank and inhabitants, he probably would have noticed his fish acting funny and could have prevented their demise.

Just my .02

I also agree that adding a bunch of "bottle cures" is definitely not the answer in reefer and will generally just lighten your pocket book and potentially cause issues down the road.
 
There was definitely something else going on there. I have been dosing for over a year and a half and never had any issues. Even when I first started out I picked up the wrong syringe on my 4th dose and dosed 2ml instead of .2ml and nothing happened to my fish,coral or tank in general. It's not for everyone. But like you said I read up for some time before tried it.
 
I'll stick to dosing myself and watch the tank as I do it.That seems to work for me.I have read alot and understand both sides but have'nt enough of an issue to consider taking the shot yet.
 
I'll stick to dosing myself and watch the tank as I do it.That seems to work for me.I have read alot and understand both sides but have'nt enough of an issue to consider taking the shot yet.

sounds like you have taken lots of shots. :feel_good:
 
I tried it when I had my 220 set up. I followed the dosing instructions to the letter and erred on the low side when calculating total water volume. i.e. I used 250 gal for calculations and I had a 75 gallon sump....anyway, the corals ALL turned brown and I got this really strange algea growing on my rocks. I kept up with it for about another week (1.5 months total by this time) and things did not improve. So I did a couple of 25% water changes. Put calerpa and chaeto in my fuge and things started to color back up in about 2 weeks. I will not do the vodka dosing EVER AGAIN!! While it did keep the phosphate and nitrate undetectable it really messed my tank up. I acheived the same parameters with small frequent water changes (5% a week) and macro algae and the tank looked better. This may be just my tank/experience but I thought I share my story.

Dave
 
I tried it when I had my 220 set up. I followed the dosing instructions to the letter and erred on the low side when calculating total water volume. i.e. I used 250 gal for calculations and I had a 75 gallon sump....anyway, the corals ALL turned brown and I got this really strange algea growing on my rocks. I kept up with it for about another week (1.5 months total by this time) and things did not improve. So I did a couple of 25% water changes. Put calerpa and chaeto in my fuge and things started to color back up in about 2 weeks. I will not do the vodka dosing EVER AGAIN!! While it did keep the phosphate and nitrate undetectable it really messed my tank up. I acheived the same parameters with small frequent water changes (5% a week) and macro algae and the tank looked better. This may be just my tank/experience but I thought I share my story.

Dave

Dave

Thanks for the feedback and post.

I just can't imagine why adding a poison to your tank is better then adding plant life. It just makes no sense to me.

My .02
 
After my "experiment" with it, I will not recommend it to ANYONE!! Macro is the way to go!!
 
One day I’m going to experiment with pickle juice.

  • It has pickling lime aka kalk for calcium and alkalinity
  • It has garlic for fish health and ick prevention
  • It has vinegar for carbon source to feed bacteria which reduce nitrates
  • It even has a green color like phytoplankton so maybe the filter feeders can benefit.
Heck maybe just dose pickles too since the tangs may eat them.

Seriously everyone should find what works for them and stick to it whether it’s bare bottom algae turf scrubbers, undergravel
filters, or vodka dosing. It doesn’t matter which leg goes in your pants first as long as you get them on.

Hmmmm…. Maybe I should use kosher dills so my rabbi fish can eat too.


Jack
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.7%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.5%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 9.9%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.5%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.4%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.0%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 24 26.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.7%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new