Why can’t I keep corals alive

Shawnfish1122

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2026
Messages
65
Reaction score
32
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Is my toadstool dead
20260214_083351_0C25BF0E-1984-4615-B231-565EF1563432.png
its first day in tank. I don’t know why I can’t keep them alive my tank is 6 month mature

Also I think my mushroom coral is not so well
20260214_083440_DF423C9E-130E-47A6-8B6F-1422741BFA70.png
 
the toadstool is not dead at all, its just slumped over. Corals need lights, flow and nutrients to survive, please tell us about your lights flow and parameters
 
the toadstool is not dead at all, its just slumped over. Corals need lights, flow and nutrients to survive, please tell us about your lights flow and parameters
I’m running a nicrew 65 watt and I’m trying to give indirect flow, parameters : temp 78 no ammonia no nitrate like five ppm nitrate and calcium-550 mg/l Phosphate is something around that what else do I test?
20260214_091449_0011C6FE-2AFA-4739-B715-743627EF74D1.png
 
What are the water parameters? What test kits are you using? What is the water temp? What lights are you running?
I’m running a nicrew 65 watt and I’m trying to give indirect flow, parameters : temp 78 no ammonia no nitrate like five ppm nitrate and calcium-550 mg/l Phosphate is something around that what else do I test?
20260214_091906_74BA9446-36CF-46D6-960D-E40BEB507BC2.png
 
I’ve moved mine between several tanks now, and it does seem to have a reaction similar to this, I haven’t had it all the way down like that but I think it’s just adjusting. These are very hardy corals, however when they get moved or shifted their foot needs to adjust, it doesn’t move around per se but it should adjust over a day or two. Then pop itself back up
 
I’ve moved mine between several tanks now, and it does seem to have a reaction similar to this, I haven’t had it all the way down like that but I think it’s just adjusting. These are very hardy corals, however when they get moved or shifted their foot needs to adjust, it doesn’t move around per se but it should adjust over a day or two. Then pop itself back up
I pray
 
I’ve moved mine between several tanks now, and it does seem to have a reaction similar to this, I haven’t had it all the way down like that but I think it’s just adjusting. These are very hardy corals, however when they get moved or shifted their foot needs to adjust, it doesn’t move around per se but it should adjust over a day or two. Then pop itself back up

I just noticed the mushroom as well. If your temps are okay, and salinity how far from the water level are your lights and what level are you running them at?
Flow isn’t too high? Should be rather gentle on them.
 
I’ve moved mine between several tanks now, and it does seem to have a reaction similar to this, I haven’t had it all the way down like that but I think it’s just adjusting. These are very hardy corals, however when they get moved or shifted their foot needs to adjust, it doesn’t move around per se but it should adjust over a day or two. Then pop itself back up
Zx- Pointing up.gif
That
 
I’ve moved mine between several tanks now, and it does seem to have a reaction similar to this, I haven’t had it all the way down like that but I think it’s just adjusting. These are very hardy corals, however when they get moved or shifted their foot needs to adjust, it doesn’t move around per se but it should adjust over a day or two. Then pop itself back up

I just noticed the mushroom as well. If your temps are okay, and salinity how far from the water level are your lights and what level are you running them at?
Flow isn’t too high? Should be rather gentle on them.
Yeah I’m going easy on it hopefully it will bounce back light is probably about foot and couple inches from water
 
btw, in a week (and occasionally in the future) it may basically shed its skin on top. Nothing to worry about, it's normal. Also, what type of mushroom is that? Ricordia can be tough to keep alive in a new tank.
 
btw, in a week (and occasionally in the future) it may basically shed its skin on top. Nothing to worry about, it's normal. Also, what type of mushroom is that? Ricordia can be tough to keep alive in a new tank.
My tank has been running for 6 months and I introduced the coral yesterday it was called “leather toadstool sacrophython”
 
My tank has been running for 6 months and I introduced the coral yesterday it was called “leather toadstool sacrophython”
That’s the leather corals name. John is asking about this
1771081889200.png
 
What are you running the lights at?
 
Take some video, post it on youtube, and then post the link here so we can see what flow looks like.

If nitrates are zero (your statement was confusing), that's not good, you need nitrates to feed the corals.

Toadstools like a good medium+ flow. So get it in some more flow.... it'll probably perk right up.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW MUCH DOES A FISH’S FEEDING REQUIREMENTS AFFECT YOUR STOCKING DECISIONS?

  • A lot! - I avoid fish that require frequent or specialized feeding

    Votes: 16 32.7%
  • Quite a bit, but an automatic feeder can change my answer

    Votes: 6 12.2%
  • It depends on whether my nutrient export can handle it

    Votes: 7 14.3%
  • It depends on how badly I want the fish

    Votes: 11 22.4%
  • Not much. I’m willing to adjust my routine

    Votes: 9 18.4%
  • Not at all. Feeding demands don’t limit my stocking choices

    Votes: 8 16.3%
  • I usually learn about the demanding feeding schedule after buying the fish!

    Votes: 2 4.1%
  • I haven’t really considered this before

    Votes: 4 8.2%
  • Something else (see my comments in the thread)

    Votes: 1 2.0%

New Posts

Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new