Yea or nay on acclimation box

[jasonrusso]

I have a harlequin tusk in QT right now. He's going into the DT in a week or so.

I had another thread and most of the members recommended using an acclimation box. I've never used an acclimation box before. I have always thought that the fish need to "sort it out" on their own. I've witnessed some territorial disputes, but never more than a day or so.

The main "bully" in the tank is a bi-color angel. When I introduced my dwarf lion 4 months ago, the angel nipped the lion's tail until they figured out whose cave belonged to who. This lasted for maybe 2 days. Now the lion sleeps out in the open and there is no problem.

The tusk is still a juvenile (has the spots), but is the same size (if not bigger) than the angel.

I understand the concept of the acclimation box, but I don't know if it will have any effect on territorial disputes. Any territorial issues would still have to be worked out. I also kind of feel like it would be stressful for the new fish. He is going from a 20L into a small box where he can see shelter but can't get to it. I am also afraid that my puffer will swim into it and knock it off the glass.

Please, tell me any positive or negative acclimation box stories.

 

[geddavis]

I would highly recommend a acclimation box. It slows the fish to get familiar with each other and helps stop a lot of aggression. I would recommend putting some macro algae in the box if it is on the larger side to provide shelter.

 

[cancun]

There are pros and cons. I don't use one. I have 14 Wrasses in my tank.....they had to work out there issues, usually took a day or so. On occasion when I had my 80 gallon tank I had to pull the aggressor out. I haven't had that trouble in my 200 gallon. I think it is up to each individual though. Just be prepared if the aggression is to much or lasts to long to remove the aggressor..... because in my experience it usually doesn't get better.

 

[jasonrusso]

I guess I am trying it out tomorrow morning!

 

[LesPoissons]

I like having one on hand in case issues develop. It's also helpful if you get something from LiveAquaria or somewhere with a guarantee- easy to keep the fish in one place so if it dies, you have a body.

 

[jasonrusso]

He is in there