Advice: Innovative Marine or Red Sea?

gfhughes

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 3, 2025
Messages
23
Reaction score
14
Location
USA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
New to the hobby, and have about 41" of wall space I can put a tank. I am ready to click the buy button and I have done a lot of research, but can't decide on the tank. I plan to keep LPS & fish, no interest in SPS.

My key criteria is success in keeping fish & coral and low maintenance. I want the hobby to be enjoying the fish not only maintenance. I don't want to build a stand or cut & glue PVC, so I am looking for a tank + stand + necessary plumbing.

RedSea Nano Max XXL (BRS Link)​

The RedSea Nano XXL seems absolutely perfect! It is my top pick except for 1 major con below.
Pros to this tank:
  • Flip-down piece to hide all the equipment (passes the ascetic test of my family)
  • 10% water change is just a 5 gallon bucket,
  • Cabinet has plenty of room for a 10 gallon ATO
  • Cheapest option (since it includes reasonable lights & skimmer)
Con: we have all read about the seemingly disproportionate failures of Red Sea tanks. I find it hard to imagine they are as successful as they are if it is true, but it is also impossible to ignore all the reported failures.

Innovative Marine SR60 (BRS Link)​

People seem happy with this tank, though there are some downsides
  • Really Shallow (only about 14" of water) all owners seem to complain about this
  • Need to buy a skimmer (Tunze 9004 skimmer, which seems underpowered)
  • Need lighting (not sure I want to shell out for XR15s, was thinking maybe Maxspect MJ-290)
  • No perfect roller-mat solution
  • Ugly because the equipment will be visible (especially If I try to fit a roller mat or 2)

Innovative Marine INT75 (BRS Link)​

Feels like the big-boy league at this point. Cons
  • 100gallons of total volume means more annoying water changes (2x 5 gallon buckets)
  • Skimmer will be quite a bit more expensive (though better)
  • No way to add a roller mat into that sump (seems others have tried). I don't want to be changing socks 2x a week
  • Most expensive option by far
  • No room in the sump at all for ATO or dosing containers (pretty big con...)
Any advice or guidance would be greatly appreciated. I know most of the RedSea failures were larger tanks, but it seems the G2 models are also failing, even the nano tanks in the middle of the front panel.

I know, Glasscages are the best, but they are way out of my budget.
 
Side Note, Innovative Marine seems to be wrong on the capacity of their tanks. For example the SR60 dimensions compute to 54 gallons, not 60:
(35.43in - 10mm - 10mm) * (23.62in - 10mm - 10mm) * (16.14in - 10mm) = 53.9 gallons

And the INT 75 which is "75 gallons" is only 63 gallons:
(35.4in - 15mm - 15mm) * (23.6in - 15mm - 15mm) * (19.7in - 15mm) = 63.4 gallons

That is 15% less volume than advertised.
 
"Any advice or guidance would be greatly appreciated"

- No RedSea.

I have a 55Gallon system,
i love the fact that just 1x 5gallons bucket is enough.

I don't like the fact that i can't have tang and other "bigger fish".
 
Side Note, Innovative Marine seems to be wrong on the capacity of their tanks. For example the SR60 dimensions compute to 54 gallons, not 60:
(35.43in - 10mm - 10mm) * (23.62in - 10mm - 10mm) * (16.14in - 10mm) = 53.9 gallons

And the INT 75 which is "75 gallons" is only 63 gallons:
(35.4in - 15mm - 15mm) * (23.6in - 15mm - 15mm) * (19.7in - 15mm) = 63.4 gallons

That is 15% less volume than advertised.
I'd go Innovative Marine over Red Sea all day, and I think most tank manufacturers give the volume based on the exterior dimensions, not the interior dims 🤪
 
I don't like the fact that i can't have tang and other "bigger fish".
Yea, my wife really wants a yellow tang, but even if I went with the 75 gallon I think the length isn't enough for a fully-grown one.
 
Im vs red sea is like Lexus vs jeep. One of them has a good chance of breaking down. It isn't IM.
lol

Lots of red sea hate, never owned a redsea tank/light but I use their dosing system to good results lol, I believe redsea is just rebranded guangzhou products anyway

Also, a brand thats really slept on but never leaked on me is Marineland, might not be as "flashy" but is my go to/ best for long term (what id trust in my home) , I have a 14 year old marineland that hasn't had a hitch and, glass handles scraping well , The silicone on marinelands is really good, only challenge is finding some dead stock marineland tanks or one for your perfect size
 
New to the hobby, and have about 41" of wall space I can put a tank. I am ready to click the buy button and I have done a lot of research, but can't decide on the tank. I plan to keep LPS & fish, no interest in SPS.

My key criteria is success in keeping fish & coral and low maintenance. I want the hobby to be enjoying the fish not only maintenance. I don't want to build a stand or cut & glue PVC, so I am looking for a tank + stand + necessary plumbing.

RedSea Nano Max XXL (BRS Link)​

The RedSea Nano XXL seems absolutely perfect! It is my top pick except for 1 major con below.
Pros to this tank:
  • Flip-down piece to hide all the equipment (passes the ascetic test of my family)
  • 10% water change is just a 5 gallon bucket,
  • Cabinet has plenty of room for a 10 gallon ATO
  • Cheapest option (since it includes reasonable lights & skimmer)
Con: we have all read about the seemingly disproportionate failures of Red Sea tanks. I find it hard to imagine they are as successful as they are if it is true, but it is also impossible to ignore all the reported failures.

Innovative Marine SR60 (BRS Link)​

People seem happy with this tank, though there are some downsides
  • Really Shallow (only about 14" of water) all owners seem to complain about this
  • Need to buy a skimmer (Tunze 9004 skimmer, which seems underpowered)
  • Need lighting (not sure I want to shell out for XR15s, was thinking maybe Maxspect MJ-290)
  • No perfect roller-mat solution
  • Ugly because the equipment will be visible (especially If I try to fit a roller mat or 2)

Innovative Marine INT75 (BRS Link)​

Feels like the big-boy league at this point. Cons
  • 100gallons of total volume means more annoying water changes (2x 5 gallon buckets)
  • Skimmer will be quite a bit more expensive (though better)
  • No way to add a roller mat into that sump (seems others have tried). I don't want to be changing socks 2x a week
  • Most expensive option by far
  • No room in the sump at all for ATO or dosing containers (pretty big con...)
Any advice or guidance would be greatly appreciated. I know most of the RedSea failures were larger tanks, but it seems the G2 models are also failing, even the nano tanks in the middle of the front panel.

I know, Glasscages are the best, but they are way out of my budget.
Don't buy a red sea
 
So if we narrow it down to IM, which tank do you think will be better with my goals of low maintenance but also success keeping fish and corals alive and happy?
 
New to the hobby, and have about 41" of wall space I can put a tank. I am ready to click the buy button and I have done a lot of research, but can't decide on the tank. I plan to keep LPS & fish, no interest in SPS.

My key criteria is success in keeping fish & coral and low maintenance. I want the hobby to be enjoying the fish not only maintenance. I don't want to build a stand or cut & glue PVC, so I am looking for a tank + stand + necessary plumbing.

RedSea Nano Max XXL (BRS Link)​

The RedSea Nano XXL seems absolutely perfect! It is my top pick except for 1 major con below.
Pros to this tank:
  • Flip-down piece to hide all the equipment (passes the ascetic test of my family)
  • 10% water change is just a 5 gallon bucket,
  • Cabinet has plenty of room for a 10 gallon ATO
  • Cheapest option (since it includes reasonable lights & skimmer)
Con: we have all read about the seemingly disproportionate failures of Red Sea tanks. I find it hard to imagine they are as successful as they are if it is true, but it is also impossible to ignore all the reported failures.

Innovative Marine SR60 (BRS Link)​

People seem happy with this tank, though there are some downsides
  • Really Shallow (only about 14" of water) all owners seem to complain about this
  • Need to buy a skimmer (Tunze 9004 skimmer, which seems underpowered)
  • Need lighting (not sure I want to shell out for XR15s, was thinking maybe Maxspect MJ-290)
  • No perfect roller-mat solution
  • Ugly because the equipment will be visible (especially If I try to fit a roller mat or 2)

Innovative Marine INT75 (BRS Link)​

Feels like the big-boy league at this point. Cons
  • 100gallons of total volume means more annoying water changes (2x 5 gallon buckets)
  • Skimmer will be quite a bit more expensive (though better)
  • No way to add a roller mat into that sump (seems others have tried). I don't want to be changing socks 2x a week
  • Most expensive option by far
  • No room in the sump at all for ATO or dosing containers (pretty big con...)
Any advice or guidance would be greatly appreciated. I know most of the RedSea failures were larger tanks, but it seems the G2 models are also failing, even the nano tanks in the middle of the front panel.

I know, Glasscages are the best, but they are way out of my budget.
I have the SR60. Trying to sell it, actually, after an upgrade. The display area is a 40 breeder. Whatever that comes to in gallons, I’m not sure. Their auto roller mat is quite great - though very visible.
 
So if we narrow it down to IM, which tank do you think will be better with my goals of low maintenance but also success keeping fish and corals alive and happy?

I think having a sump on a larger system makes life easier. It looks cleaner and other than having to figure out how to use it initially it will make it a lot more enjoyable. If you can afford the cost for equipment and other accessories than that would be the way I would go.
 
I have the SR60. Trying to sell it, actually, after an upgrade. The display area is a 40 breeder. Whatever that comes to in gallons, I’m not sure. Their auto roller mat is quite great - though very visible.
Sorry, many questions (the tank seem like the hardest thing to change in the future, unlike a light or powerhead decision)

How long did you have the SR60?
How did you like it?
Why did you upgrade?
What equipment did you run in the tank?
 
I know I'm going against what most people say on here, but for a beginner I would say Red Sea, only because it comes with pretty much everything you need. All you need to get is a heater, a wavemaker, and some stuff for the pump. I own a Red Sea and haven't had any seam failures YET. I am keeping a 33 gallon and, Tang police pls don't, have a tomini Tang in it and it is very happy right now. I haven't owned any other tanks, but I would just recommend Red Sea because it is beginner friendly. However, you should be ready for seam failures and get a leak detector. Also, you might want to get some small storage shelves for under the tank, as there is a lot of empty room without them. Here is a pic of my Red Sea Nano XL:
image0 (17).jpeg
 
I think 48 inch allows a yellow tang imo. Waterbox are good as well. The IM100 is prob the smallest that works for that fish long term.
 
I have the SR60. Trying to sell it, actually, after an upgrade. The display area is a 40 breeder. Whatever that comes to in gallons, I’m not sure. Their auto roller mat is quite great - though very visible.
Sorry, many questions (the tank seem like the hardest thing to change in the future, unlike a light or powerhead decision)

How long did you have the SR60?
How did you like it?
Why did you upgrade?
What equipment did you run in the tank?
I ran it about 2.5 years. I liked it, but upgraded to a bigger system built into the wall with a basement sump. I had algae issues since I started with dry rock, so at the end I was using a Tunze MAR. It did a great job managing my nutrients, and grew chaeto like crazy, but never solved my algae issue. I had 2 AI Hydra 32 lights. I used the auto roller on one side and the media caddy on the other. Used carbon & custom cut floss squares in the caddy. I have a skimmer, but did not have room for it with all the other stuff. It’s a CADLights. Pretty rare but worked well when I was using in. Prior to the auto roller, I used the manual one. Beats a sock, but I had to turn it twice a day or so.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 20 26.3%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 6 7.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 28 36.8%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.6%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 20 26.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new