Copper removal help

  • Thread starter Thread starter sevitz5
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

sevitz5

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 29, 2017
Messages
696
Reaction score
133
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I purchase a branching rock at my lfs tonight that I found out had been in copper. I want to figure out how I can make this rock reef safe before I add it to my tank. Throwing it out, or returning it is not an option since I haven’t been able to find branch rock around me for well over a year. What is a good way to remove the copper? Thanks.
 
I purchase a branching rock at my lfs tonight that I found out had been in copper. I want to figure out how I can make this rock reef safe before I add it to my tank. Throwing it out, or returning it is not an option since I haven’t been able to find branch rock around me for well over a year. What is a good way to remove the copper? Thanks.
Sorry to say.. its not worth having that rock in your tank if you are going to add corals or invertebrates
 
I purchase a branching rock at my lfs tonight that I found out had been in copper. I want to figure out how I can make this rock reef safe before I add it to my tank. Throwing it out, or returning it is not an option since I haven’t been able to find branch rock around me for well over a year. What is a good way to remove the copper? Thanks.
I would soak the rock for several weeks in a solution of EDTA, which will tightly bind the copper ions impregnated in the rock (purchase here: https://www.loudwolf.com/storefront/index.php?route=product/product&path=687&product_id=1724). Submerse in RO/DI water and add 0.5-1 oz of EDTA. After soaking in EDTA, discard the water and soak in RO/DI water for another week.
 
I would soak the rock for several weeks in a solution of EDTA, which will tightly bind the copper ions impregnated in the rock (purchase here: https://www.loudwolf.com/storefront/index.php?route=product/product&path=687&product_id=1724). Submerse in RO/DI water and add 0.5-1 oz of EDTA. After soaking in EDTA, discard the water and soak in RO/DI water for another week.
Is this the same? It’s the EDTA we use at work. It’s just the powder form we mix with DI water.
98BFE39F-4DA7-46ED-8B37-440D0733EDAD.jpeg
 
Yes, that will probably work, but you need to rinse very well before using the rock. Getting substantial EDTA into the tank is not desirable, IMO, as it may make a number of trace elements less bioavailable.

My typical suggestion is to expose the rock to acid (such as straight vinegar) and dissolve off a very thin outer layer. Then you can treat further, if you wish, by soaking in a solution with a metal binder in it (like cuprisorb).
 
I would rather return that rock than not having a piece of mind in future.

Everytime a coral or invert dies, my 1st question would be... Is it the copper leaching out again?

If there is still residual copper, you exposed all your rocks in DT now, what do you do then?

Get all new rocks?
 
I appreciate all the help. My main problem is, in Ohio where I’m at, I can’t get a rock like this anywhere. I have been looking for the last 2 years. I am going to cut the small branches off and use them to mount some SPS Frags up off my existing rock work.
 
I appreciate all the help. My main problem is, in Ohio where I’m at, I can’t get a rock like this anywhere. I have been looking for the last 2 years. I am going to cut the small branches off and use them to mount some SPS Frags up off my existing rock work.
Just to clarify, you are looking around your LFS, right? Cause I am pretty sure some online vendors have them.
I understand it's not cheap to ship
 
Just to clarify, you are looking around your LFS, right? Cause I am pretty sure some online vendors have them.
I understand it's not cheap to ship
All I can find is over $100 for a piece from online vendors. I only need 5 or 6 of the small branches off 1 big branch like I have.
 
All I can find is over $100 for a piece from online vendors. I only need 5 or 6 of the small branches off 1 big branch like I have.
Aquatic Technology in Lorain County has some still with feather dusters and such, I have some, it’s pretty diverse. I can’t speak on his price as I jacked him outta friendship LOL. I’ll take a pic in 8 min
 
pardon the purple light, t5 ....I added in white led hope that helped
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    219.5 KB · Views: 68
  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    221.2 KB · Views: 82
I got these (sans euphillias) from Salty Critter in Vermillion, I’d call 1st as I took all I could :D
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    241.2 KB · Views: 79
  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    236 KB · Views: 55
There are also manmade variations out there now.
Exactly....Might be relevant to ask if you want “ole School” real submerged branch or once dry cycled stuff? Big difference in price to be sure. Also be advised the live stuff can have unwanted(s)
 
I appreciate all the help. My main problem is, in Ohio where I’m at, I can’t get a rock like this anywhere. I have been looking for the last 2 years. I am going to cut the small branches off and use them to mount some SPS Frags up off my existing rock work.
I think you can safely remove the copper using EDTA. As Randy pointed out it also important to remove the EDTA, which is why I suggested soaking in water for another week following the initial EDTA treatment. To help remove any EDTA you could also soak in some mild acid overnight as this would help remove any EDTA bound to the rock. I think this would be safe and effective. There are also biodegradable chelating agents you can use such as nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA), ethylenediaminedisuccinic acid (EDDS), and iminodisuccinic acid (IDS). I have attached a review on these if you're interested. I would soak the rock in these compounds for 3 days (maybe repeat once for another 3 days with fresh compound), then in water for a week or two. Any residual chelating agents left in the rock will degrade in a few weeks, so you won't have any contamination.
 

Attachments

I think you can safely remove the copper using EDTA. As Randy pointed out it also important to remove the EDTA, which is why I suggested soaking in water for another week following the initial EDTA treatment. To help remove any EDTA you could also soak in some mild acid overnight as this would help remove any EDTA bound to the rock. I think this would be safe and effective. There are also biodegradable chelating agents you can use such as nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA), ethylenediaminedisuccinic acid (EDDS), and iminodisuccinic acid (IDS). I have attached a review on these if you're interested. I would soak the rock in these compounds for 3 days (maybe repeat once for another 3 days with fresh compound), then in water for a week or two. Any residual chelating agents left in the rock will degrade in a few weeks, so you won't have any contamination.
I currently have the rock soaking in 3 gallon of RODI water. How much EDTA do I use? Is there a ratio? Thanks
 
I currently have the rock soaking in 3 gallon of RODI water. How much EDTA do I use? Is there a ratio? Thanks

It won't require much to eventually pull it out, but twice as much might go about twice as fast (not really certain as I'm not sure what the slow step is, or even what the molecular level process is: copper comes off the solid surface and into the waiting arms of EDTA, or EDTA helping to actually pull it off).

I see no reason to not use a substantial amount since it may not be a fast process to begin with.
 
I currently have the rock soaking in 3 gallon of RODI water. How much EDTA do I use? Is there a ratio? Thanks
I would suggest 1-2 grams per gallon. This would give you about 250-500 ppm EDTA, which is more than you need.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 9 69.2%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new