I have a small tank, 20g long, and I was doing just water changes to keep alk/calcium where I wanted, but with only 4 fish, I don't have much bioload, so I quickly bottomed out nitrate and phosphate to 0. Which now I'm dealing with dinos from that. For now I stopped waterchanges and am dosing no4 and po3, and dosing for alk or calcium as needed.
I definitely think every tank is just too different to put a catch all solution to. Some can get away with just waterchanges, some you can't. Some can change no water and just dose. Some you can't. Finding out what works for you and your tank is the fun part :)