Help Picking an AIO

[JayReefs97]

Hello all,

I am looking to purchase an AIO tank for my new place. I am looking for a tank of a minimum of 50 gallons and max of 70, I would prefer an AIO over a sump as I will be on hardwood floors and I have heard more sump & plumbing leak stories over the safety of an AIO - is this correct? I am between a few but want other opinions.

#1 Option - JBJ RF-65 Rimless Flat Panel AIO - Much cheaper than alternatives and on sale through BRS. Anyone have any experience with the JBJ tanks?

The waterbox 50.3 or 65.4 - I like the dimensions of but have seen very sparse information or videos on this tank. - Anyone have any first hand experience?

Innovative Marine SR Pro 2 60 - I love the stand, heard great things about IM tanks and their sturdyness - lack of leaks. I do have concerns around the dimensions of it being a shallower tank that comes out further from the wall - thoughts on this?

Red sea Max Nano G2 XXL - Like everyone else I have heard of the red sea leaks - however I am getting conflicting info that the leaks are on the larger reefer tanks, not the nano's, I like the amount of info on these tanks, reef mat etc. also my LFS is a red sea dealer - save on freight cost. Let me know your thoughts.

Any other recommendations?

Thanks for the help everyone!

 

[Gumbies R Us]

You are going to get a whole range of opinions on this topic. I like my Red Sea Max nano. Never had leak issues or any complaints with mine. The only issue I have is that the skimmer and ATO that come with it are not the best. However, the overall tank is a nice tank.

 

[Acanthaopolis]

I like all of these options. I think the Red Sea has good dimensions. I would also look into the tideline aquatics 62g AIO. I like the IM but I personally wish it was just a little taller.

 

[Jamie9]

I love my IM. I also have heard great things about Waterbox, that was in the running for me as well when I bought mine. I know the Red Sea failures haven’t been with this size tank…but I’d be too terrified to have one of those in my house after all of the horror stories.

 

[Tahoe61]

Waterbox or IM. How is RedSea even on the list, over priced and questionable customer service.

 

[jpmazzone]

I have an IM AIO Lagoon 50. It is great. No problems after one year. very straight forward and easy to run. I used to have a Waterbox. It looked nice but, the IM stand is far better and the glass is much more durable. The Waterbox scratched very easily despite taking great care. Good luck!

 

[KrankBait]

I have my eye on the UNS 90LA. Dimensions are unique.

 

[steveschuerger]

Honestly for me, I’d get the SR60 from IM. Had one before. Sure it’s a shallow reef style but I think that works out to its benefit. And it’s not too shallow at 16.5 inches high total in my opinion. This was mine. Lots of space, but not overwhelming.

 

[jpmazzone]

One more thing. If you are going after an IM, they seem to go on sale quite a bit in the summer. If you can, you should wait until then.

 

[kitti-fish]

Regarding leaks: anything can leaks
Seams will eventually fail or an accident can cause damage and break the tank. It’s best to go with a tank with a good reputation from the company. I think the rule of thumb is most tanks should last 10 or so years before any failure may arise although some reefers have tanks that are 20+ years. AIO waterbox was my choice before I went with a sump. I believe Innovative Marine is also a good and well respected company.