Hey All, I'm having an issue with my Frogspawn not wanting to extend and a possible hitchhiker that may be the cause so just looking for confirmation.
Some background (Tank Parameters are at the end of the post):
-Purchased this piece about 3 weeks ago. Flesh band was healthy and thick extending about a full inch down the skeleton
-Got it home and gave it a thorough dip with Polyp Lab's Reef Primer, followed by a bath in some Lugol's solution.
-It went in the tank and opened up fully within the first 3 hours.
-For 2 weeks, the coral seemed perfectly fine and fully inflated.
Now last week, I noticed the coral extending about half as much as usual, and by the end of the week, not extending at all. I noticed a large red/pink line on the skeleton. At first this almost looked like paint however I noticed it seemed to move slightly day to day. My first thought was a flatworm but after comparing pictures online and given the size of it I dismissed it as a possibility.
The red patch got quite large so I decided to remove the coral and try a dip in a different dip solution (Fauna Marin's The Dip). When I took it out of the dip, I used a small plastic tool just to try and scrape the red patch to see if it could be removed. I wish I grabbed pictures of this but it seemed to scrape like jelly and in to small clumps. I still thought it had to be some type of flat worm so I used a small Q tip and dipped in Hydrogen Peroxide and carefully dabbed it on the red spot. Parts of it immediately turned white so I cleared as much as I could and rinsed it before placing back in the tank.
It's now been 2 days and I can see some of the red coming back. The pictures attached are what the coral looks like now and the red coming back. For reference the red patches were at least double the size as pictured.
My theory is whatever this is is irritating the flesh band as I do see some recession now. I have inspected the only other LPS corals I have in the tank which are 3 torches and some gonis, none of them have any signs of this red patch, and are all extended normally.
Many thanks for your help in advance, I hope I've provided enough info/detail to go on.
Here are some tank parameters and other tank info:
Tank: Water Box Peninsula Mini 25
Age: Tank is about 5 months old
Salinity: 35ppt (I check this every other day and my refractometer is calibrated each time with a 35ppt reference solution)
Temp: 77.5 - 78
Calcium: 440
Mag: 1400
Alk: 8-8.5 (Checked Daily with Hanna and once a week verified with Salifert)
Nitrates: 10ppm
Phos: 0.02
Water Changes: 10% Weekly every Friday
Salt Used: Fauna Marin
Fish Stock List:
2x Thunder Maroon Clowns
1x Pajama Cardinal
1x Orchid Dotty
1x Cleaner Shrimp
2x Conches
x10-15 Snales (variety of Trochus, Nassarius, and Astrea)
Coral Stock List:
Monti Digis
Pocilloporas
Large variety of Zoas
Goniopora
GSP (Isolated on a rock island)
Lepto colonies
2x Rock Flower Anemones
Variety of Mushrooms
Torches
1x Frogspawn (the issue)
Feeding & Dosing:
All for Reef on a dosing pump (5ml/day).
Brightwell Aquatics Coral Amino (8 drops/day)
Fauna Marin Soft Pellets, Frozen Mysis, and occasionally LRS Reef Frenzy Nano
Other equipment and filter media:
Filter Floss
Polyplab Genesis Rock in the AIO chamber
Bubble Magnus Mini Q Skimmer
Tunze Osmolator Nano ATO
Nicrew Gen 2 100 - (Frogspawn is sitting at about 150 PAR)

Some background (Tank Parameters are at the end of the post):
-Purchased this piece about 3 weeks ago. Flesh band was healthy and thick extending about a full inch down the skeleton
-Got it home and gave it a thorough dip with Polyp Lab's Reef Primer, followed by a bath in some Lugol's solution.
-It went in the tank and opened up fully within the first 3 hours.
-For 2 weeks, the coral seemed perfectly fine and fully inflated.
Now last week, I noticed the coral extending about half as much as usual, and by the end of the week, not extending at all. I noticed a large red/pink line on the skeleton. At first this almost looked like paint however I noticed it seemed to move slightly day to day. My first thought was a flatworm but after comparing pictures online and given the size of it I dismissed it as a possibility.
The red patch got quite large so I decided to remove the coral and try a dip in a different dip solution (Fauna Marin's The Dip). When I took it out of the dip, I used a small plastic tool just to try and scrape the red patch to see if it could be removed. I wish I grabbed pictures of this but it seemed to scrape like jelly and in to small clumps. I still thought it had to be some type of flat worm so I used a small Q tip and dipped in Hydrogen Peroxide and carefully dabbed it on the red spot. Parts of it immediately turned white so I cleared as much as I could and rinsed it before placing back in the tank.
It's now been 2 days and I can see some of the red coming back. The pictures attached are what the coral looks like now and the red coming back. For reference the red patches were at least double the size as pictured.
My theory is whatever this is is irritating the flesh band as I do see some recession now. I have inspected the only other LPS corals I have in the tank which are 3 torches and some gonis, none of them have any signs of this red patch, and are all extended normally.
Many thanks for your help in advance, I hope I've provided enough info/detail to go on.
Here are some tank parameters and other tank info:
Tank: Water Box Peninsula Mini 25
Age: Tank is about 5 months old
Salinity: 35ppt (I check this every other day and my refractometer is calibrated each time with a 35ppt reference solution)
Temp: 77.5 - 78
Calcium: 440
Mag: 1400
Alk: 8-8.5 (Checked Daily with Hanna and once a week verified with Salifert)
Nitrates: 10ppm
Phos: 0.02
Water Changes: 10% Weekly every Friday
Salt Used: Fauna Marin
Fish Stock List:
2x Thunder Maroon Clowns
1x Pajama Cardinal
1x Orchid Dotty
1x Cleaner Shrimp
2x Conches
x10-15 Snales (variety of Trochus, Nassarius, and Astrea)
Coral Stock List:
Monti Digis
Pocilloporas
Large variety of Zoas
Goniopora
GSP (Isolated on a rock island)
Lepto colonies
2x Rock Flower Anemones
Variety of Mushrooms
Torches
1x Frogspawn (the issue)
Feeding & Dosing:
All for Reef on a dosing pump (5ml/day).
Brightwell Aquatics Coral Amino (8 drops/day)
Fauna Marin Soft Pellets, Frozen Mysis, and occasionally LRS Reef Frenzy Nano
Other equipment and filter media:
Filter Floss
Polyplab Genesis Rock in the AIO chamber
Bubble Magnus Mini Q Skimmer
Tunze Osmolator Nano ATO
Nicrew Gen 2 100 - (Frogspawn is sitting at about 150 PAR)

