All-For-Reef Powder

[34gallonSolana]

The kit is available at BRS

 

[ether]

Not yet available. However, I still think the DIY version is simple to make.

Have a link to the DIY recipe?

 

[PhilT]

Have a link to the DIY recipe?

It’s on the BRS page for the bundle.

10 Liter DIY All-For-Reef Kit

Supply your reef with all major, minor, and trace elements in a single, convenient solution! With the introduction of their Carbo-Calcium and All-For-Reef products, Tropic Marin revolutionized dosing for reef aquariums. A one part complete dosing solution sounded like a myth, but through the...

www.bulkreefsupply.com

 

[Spare time]

Have a link to the DIY recipe?

 

[thatmanMIKEson]

the powder is out in u.s now ! Just ordered some any thoughts on the product yet?

 

[Nickybfishfree]

the powder is out in u.s now ! Just ordered some any thoughts on the product yet?

I've been using the powder for the last 8 months in a new system. Seems to be keeping everything very stable and in sync for me. I'm currently dosing 29ml a day. Thus far very happy with it. It does take quite a while mixing though, I mix a litre a month

 

[thatmanMIKEson]

I've been using the powder for the last 8 months in a new system. Seems to be keeping everything very stable and in sync for me. I'm currently dosing 29ml a day. Thus far very happy with it. It does take quite a while mixing though, I mix a litre a month

I stopped using it, I was getting high magnesium and slowing snails. Do you have any mag issues

 

[Nickybfishfree]

I stopped using it, I was getting high magnesium and slowing snails. Do you have any mag issues

None what so ever, in fact I actually been adding a tiny amount of mag

 

[thatmanMIKEson]

None what so ever, in fact I actually been adding a tiny amount of mag

Do you constantly stir your mixture, I was getting a brown settling on the bottom. At first it seemed ok but I stopped testing mag and stopped stirring and let it settle out,, and mag crept up and alk was wonky but im not blaming it on AFR maybe it was my mixing .

Did yours settle out?

 

[Spare time]

I've been using the powder for the last 8 months in a new system. Seems to be keeping everything very stable and in sync for me. I'm currently dosing 29ml a day. Thus far very happy with it. It does take quite a while mixing though, I mix a litre a month

PS if you mix it in a gallon pitcher with a pump it mixes a lot quicker than shaking by hand.

 

[Spare time]

Do you constantly stir your mixture, I was getting a brown settling on the bottom. At first it seemed ok but I stopped testing mag and stopped stirring and let it settle out,, and mag crept up and alk was wonky but im not blaming it on AFR maybe it was my mixing .

Did yours settle out?

I think that is iron precipitate or something (I saw tropic marin mention this somewhere)

 

[enb141]

After about two years of the release of this product, how do you guys think about it?

 

[Reef Psychology]

After about two years of the release of this product, how do you guys think about it?

No better option for and AIO nano IMO. Started with the liquid, moved to the DIY and now using the powder. Magnesium is consumed faster than alk & calcium, but I dose a couple times a month to raise it about 100. January is ICP time and I'm sure a few trace elements are going to be off, but no dosing method is perfect. I give AFR an A overall. The only flaw is it doesn't raise pH.

 

[Reef.]

No better option for and AIO nano IMO. Started with the liquid, moved to the DIY and now using the powder. Magnesium is consumed faster than alk & calcium, but I dose a couple times a month to raise it about 100. January is ICP time and I'm sure a few trace elements are going to be off, but no dosing method is perfect. I give AFR an A overall. The only flaw is it doesn't raise pH.

That doesn’t sound right, alk and calcium are normally used at a greater rate, and to have to increase mag by 100 each month sounds abnormal.

 

[Reef Psychology]

That doesn’t sound right, alk and calcium are normally used at a greater rate, and to have to increase mag by 100 each month sounds abnormal.

Not abnormal. Different organisms uptake elements at different rates. Coralline algae, from what I've read, uptakes magnesium more quickly than calcium for example. Some replenishment systems use alkalinity while others use calcium to calculate dosage. Tropic Marin's AFR ionic balanced approach is great, but it cannot account for all situations. Eventually, something will deplete faster than the others.

 

[ShadowMan]

Hi all -
I have just mixed up my first batch (1.5L), it does indeed have a very slight tint to it. I was going to buy one of those cheap magnetic stirrers but decided to try adding the RO and powder to a 2L bottle and shaking it. Shake for 30 seconds, stood for a minute, repeated this another 2 times and thats it, its mixed really well.

I bought a cheap magnetic stirrer from Amazon for £35.

HYCC Magnetic Stirrer, 3000 RPM Magnetic Mixer, Stir Plate Max Stirring Liquid 3 Liters, Lab Stirrers with 7PCS stir bar Set and stir bar Retriever (UK PLUG) : Amazon.co.uk: Business, Industry & Science

Buy HYCC Magnetic Stirrer, 3000 RPM Magnetic Mixer, Stir Plate Max Stirring Liquid 3 Liters, Lab Stirrers with 7PCS stir bar Set and stir bar Retriever (UK PLUG) at Amazon UK. Free delivery on eligible orders.

amzn.eu

Coupled this with a 1L lab flask and mixing a fresh batch is a piece of cake with minimal residue. I then pour the mix into an old RS Foundation Liquid 1L bottle complete with dosing tube and it's good to go ;)

 

[nvcheeko]

Iv been using it for years still on my 800Gram, not massive dose 2ml day, Never have issue

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Not abnormal. Different organisms uptake elements at different rates. Coralline algae, from what I've read, uptakes magnesium more quickly than calcium for example. Some replenishment systems use alkalinity while others use calcium to calculate dosage. Tropic Marin's AFR ionic balanced approach is great, but it cannot account for all situations. Eventually, something will deplete faster than the others.

The 100 ppm per month seems off to me.

It is true that coralline uses magnesium faster than many corals, per unit of calcium consumed, but it's still only about 1/10th of the calcium consumption even if coralline is the only user and even if the AFR had zero magnesium in it.

That means you are consuming 1,000 ppm of calcium in a month, or 32 ppm per day of calcium and 4.8 dKH per day of alk.

That's a very high rate, IMO.

 

[Reef.]

The 100 ppm per month seems off to me.

It is true that coralline uses magnesium faster than many corals, per unit of calcium consumed, but it's still only about 1/10th of the calcium consumption even if coralline is the only user and even if the AFR had zero magnesium in it.

That means you are consuming 1,000 ppm of calcium in a month, or 32 ppm per day of calcium and 4.8 dKH per day of alk.

That's a very high rate, IMO.

Have you also factored in the mg, alk and calcium the AFR is adding? The 100ppm mag dosing was just the extra mag the op was dosing on top of the AFR.

 

[Reef Psychology]

The 100 ppm per month seems off to me.

It is true that coralline uses magnesium faster than many corals, per unit of calcium consumed, but it's still only about 1/10th of the calcium consumption even if coralline is the only user and even if the AFR had zero magnesium in it.

That means you are consuming 1,000 ppm of calcium in a month, or 32 ppm per day of calcium and 4.8 dKH per day of alk.

That's a very high rate, IMO.

Perhaps I’m not adding enough to the mix during water changes. I’ll test next weekend. Thanks Randy!