Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Not sure why you think Ecotech are heading towards Orphek's design but hey oh. IMO nothing can be further than the truth. Radions appear to be the same size as the G4 , are the individual LEDs irreplaceable like the Orphek's. The Orphek's have dual diodes. One Orphek will light a 3' SPS tank well. I admit to not seeing a G5 in person so I might be wrong about them. We shall see.At this price point can’t one buy an Orphek, the design of which Ecotech seems to be headed towards?
I do think Ecotech probably should have gone to a larger panel at the same time it abandoned the puck. It seems like you ought to spread out the LEDs as far as possible without losing good blending to create the most even lighting levels possible and reduce shadowing. I'm not sure I've ever seen an Orphek Atlantik lit tank in person but, it certainly seems to check all the boxes of what I would look for if I were buying new LEDs right now. Right or wrong, I might have some concerns about reliability though.I don't think these benefits of panels are getting lost, they've just already been proven and provided by ReefBreeder and Orphek a few yrs ago to those that benefit the most from them (owners of large footprint systems).
If you're married to the Eco-Tech brand, you'll finally get to experience these benefits. But if your not, compelling budget and premium panels have existed for some time that are purpose built for larger footprints vs shoe-horned into a chassis that looks like it was meant for pucks.
That's why aquatic life will likely count on significant biz from G5 customers
These are some of the reasons I went with 2 X Atlantic V4s along with the fact if needed you can replace individual LEDs and are upgradeable if needed. Seems to me Orphek listened to many of the concerns of hobbyists and addressed them...mostly why Ecotech have stuck closely to what they have produced in the past with let's be honest success market wise. I don't see the G5 as a game changer and think Ecotech could have done more to spread the LEDs out.I do think Ecotech probably should have gone to a larger panel at the same time it abandoned the puck. It seems like you ought to spread out the LEDs as far as possible without losing good blending to create the most even lighting levels possible and reduce shadowing. I'm not sure I've ever seen an Orphek Atlantik lit tank in person but, it certainly seems to check all the boxes of what I would look for if I were buying new LEDs right now. Right or wrong, I might have some concerns about reliability though.
Matt
You don’t have to BUY ANYTHING YOU DONT LIKE THE PRICE OFI know it’s the same price as the old G4 but I’m still amazed people can and will spend $900 (with tax) on a 12 inch 100 watt LED. It truly is a light for the elite. Their advertising pull on the market is incredible. They learned the market will support $900 so they kept it that way. Everyone already has them listed online, YouTube interviews, you name it. Its an LED board, heat sink, fan and wifi chip with an app. And it’s water resistant. OMG they designed their own fan!? The advertise better blending. It’s easy to blend any LED light by using some sort of diffusing material.
For $900!? Oh and you’ll need 2-4 of them over your tank.
For me it’s a hobby and I appreciate cost effective lighting solutions. I’ve seen plenty of Radion powered tanks full of GHA (Gallery Aquatica customer tanks) and I’ve seen some black box tanks that would amaze you. Celebrating a free market! Next up G6 for $1k! Or, for me, something cheaper
Just like, YOU DON'T HAVE TO SHOUT to get your point across. However, we are discussing the merits or otherwise of a new product and it's competitor's or at least I though that was the case. It's all about choice and a point of view.You don’t have to BUY ANYTHING YOU DONT LIKE THE PRICE OF
Marketing ( some might suggest doing you over) why sell 1 light when they can sell 2, 3, or 4? Also probably more economical to produce one light than a number of varying lengths not that, that is an excuse.I am no light expert but why didn't they build the new g5 bigger so you wouldn't need as many? similar to the old maxspect razors, you could buy in 2, 3, and 4ft lengths so rather than use 3 2ft lights you could use 2 3ft lights to light a 6ft tank at a cheaper cost?
Is there a technological reason for this or is it just to sell more?
I do think Ecotech probably should have gone to a larger panel at the same time it abandoned the puck. It seems like you ought to spread out the LEDs as far as possible without losing good blending to create the most even lighting levels possible and reduce shadowing. I'm not sure I've ever seen an Orphek Atlantik lit tank in person but, it certainly seems to check all the boxes of what I would look for if I were buying new LEDs right now. Right or wrong, I might have some concerns about reliability though.
Matt
I mean I get it, the G5's aren't necessary to run a successful reef, but neither is a Trident and those are still hard to get nearly a year after release. But from watching the BRS Investigates video on them they are a game changer in eliminating hotspots and shadowing and even distribution of par in optimized spectrums. They are definitely an advancement and leading the technology in having compact LED perform near T5 standard. I doubt that they would show significant difference in a tank that is already running successfully without them but that shouldn't negate their value to someone looking for the solutions that they offer that no other LED in that compact size do. If starting a new tank or fixing lighting issues in a current tank, it could be worth the investment in the G5. If running a successful tank or feeling left out because you don't have the newest, I don't think it's worth upgrading (unless $ is zero issue).
Cant see how they have eliminated shading much as the light is still narrow unless you mount them grint to back then how many more would you need."they are a game changer in eliminating hotspots and shadowing and even distribution of par in optimized spectrums "
Not really. Orphek already did this. Ecotech is just following their lead.
"they are a game changer in eliminating hotspots and shadowing and even distribution of par in optimized spectrums "
Not really. Orphek already did this. Ecotech is just following their lead.
Cant see how they have eliminated shading much as the light is still narrow unless you mount them grint to back then how many more would you need.
Ermmm Am not taking PAR but shading. That is completely different and you can't eliminate shading g with PAR unfortunately as light wont bend.I disagree. The Orphek par distribution is still more pyramid shaped as opposed to the pancake shape of the G 5 par chart.
If you watch the BRS Investigates video it shows the par distribution chart. It's the flatest I've seen on a compact LED.
The vast majority of my equipment was bought secondhand including my Orpheks. Sometimes I even make money on what I have bought. Thank god for the most have the latest kit guys as it often means I get a bargain.Meanwhile my 200 a pop prime 16’s are growing the heck out of some corals. Although I do like to complain about things I can’t afford it’s more fun to watch others. I swear BRS and others are very good at being subtle as heck and making you think you can’t be successful without there latest and greatest stuff. Many time I have caught myself watching there videos and going right to there site to buy and coming to my senses at the last min. This hobby is very hard for people on a budget and even harder if you are on a budget but dont think you are. How many people have used the affirm option just for these lights when they have less than a year old lights over there tank with a bunch of dead and dying corals in the water? It gets easier when you dont have the money to spend on new stuff and I am amazed at what I can accomplish with third or fourth tier equipment.