So, when the first 2 died I got another one and it seemed to be fine. It started eating right away and by last week even took flakes.
It had a little cloudy pectoral fins but no significant fin damage. Yesterday evening I took a closer look and the lef fin looked like covered in mucus and I decided to treat the tank with neoplex. When I came home this evening the water was cloudy. So I did a full water change which got the Betta out of its cave and allowed me to take a closer look at it. What I saw was not good - the fish has light skin patches like the others and its left fin base is bloody. It looks like it has the same as the others.
The store where I got them all runs low dose copper and furan in their fish systems and it seems that this had helped as this one looked initially worse than the others - the reason why I didn't get it with the first lot.
So I'm wondering now what this could be if low dose copper and furan help. Furthermore I wonder if I should pull the fish out off its current quarantine tank and set up another qt for copper/furan treatment (current qt has live rock).
What worries me is that in a new sterile tank things may get worse and the fish may stop eating. I'm also not a great fan of copper or treating blindly without knowing what I'm actually up against.
So anyone having an idea what this might be?