How do you acclimate new fish?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Demonic
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Demonic

Love Change
View Badges
Joined
Nov 13, 2009
Messages
1,298
Reaction score
1,056
Location
Minot, ND
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Ok, so I have always drip acclimated new fish. I have read a few theories on how this can be more damaging than good to the fish. So I bring this topic to light to maybe introduce some new ideas. There has to be a better way I am assuming. So please post a way that we can introduce new inhabitants into our tank. Take in mind that matching temp, ph, salinity are all must haves.
 
I used to just temp acclimate, but now I'll float the bag for like 15 to 20 mins, then cut a slit on the bag and let the fish swim out on it's own, I guess it's kinda like dripping (saw the guy at a lfs doing this and his fish always look healthy)
 
i drip acclimate , I wouldn't just float the bag and then cut a slit , you don't know whats in the fish stores water . i know the fish store near me keeps all there fish in copper
 
I like to float the bag for a while to acclimate the temp, then open it and clip it to the side of the tank. I then use a turkey baster to add tank water to the bag. It is kinda like a drip but it keeps the temp consistant with the tank and not the room. I add tank water to the bag every 10-15 minutes for the biggest part of two hours, then drain the LFS water into a net over a bucket and transfer the fish. I have always had sucess with this method.

I have also see others that will float for 15 minutes and cut the bottom out of the bag???????
 
I def agree with not putting the water into my tank. I never trust their water, also the water from buying online wouldnt be too good either. The waste excreted in the water from the transport makes that water fairly nasty.
 
This is a great topic and really needs the pros and cons to be discussed. Many websites and sellers highly recommend drip acclimation. Some websites say drip for 2-3 hours. However, if you use a bucket or a stirofoam cooler, after 2 hours your water will be room temperature. So if you keep your house at 80 degrees, that wont matter, but if the room is 72, then that may do more harm than good. So a drip acclimation means a drop or 2 per second, well I drip about 6-8 drops a second and about 15-20 minutes. Then every 5 mintues add a cup of tank water and removed a cup from the bucket water. The water is added fast enough that the temperature remains at tank temp and salinity (and other components) are gradually changed.
 
This is a great topic and really needs the pros and cons to be discussed. .

This is what I was hoping to establish. Getting some people who have had a ton of fish and how they introduce them to their tank with lot fatality rates. I have just heard that alot of people just float their fish, and just wondering that more should be done to increase their chances of survival during the transition.
 
Dripping is a great way to acclimate with the only problem typically being temperature- doing a long drip of up to an hour is great for balancing out all the differences in salinity, mineral levels, et cetera, but if you have the drip container outside of the aquarium, odds are the water will cool down over that period of time. When you go to introduce the fish into the tank, they're suddenly getting temperature shocked.
Ways to prevent this is to float/attach the dripping container inside your sump, so it's kept thermally stable by the surrounding water.

Otherwise, attach a container inside the tank, and simply do the "add some water every few minutes" approach. It may be a bit rougher, especially for extremely delicate/valuable fish, but much better than doing a really good drip acclimation but ending up temperature shocking those same fish.

For typically sturdy fish, such as non-delicate wrasses (sixline, melanarus, coris), sturdy gobies (clowns, firefish) or other 'tough guys', typically a temperature acclimation can be plenty, depending on the water they're coming from. If your store is running their fish at a lowered salinity, or with medication, try and be aware of these things so you know what change the fish are going to go through. If the fish are kept in a lower salinity system, keep in mind there's more oxygen prevalent in the water they're coming from, so a sudden shift can be extremely challenging in such a case, and dripping is the much better method.


Regardless if it's from a store, or from a fellow hobbyiest, it's always best to prevent water transfer if possible. Not always needed, but there's really no downside to establishing the practice of keeping tanks separate from each other.
 
Thats acutally a great idea. I never thought of putting the container in the sump to keep temps stable. Take water from the tank and put into the container located in the sump. Great idea, keep them coming. What are some other ways
 
A big factor for me is whether the fish was purchased locally, or mail ordered. I take a bit more time with mail order fish, acclimating them to the water chemistry, not just temperature. And to reiterate, NEVER put and water from the bag into your tank, which really should be a QT tank, BTW :wink:
 
What about when you get a mail order fish/coral and add water over a period of time, doesn't the pH raise and cause ammonia to then be fatal???
 
Has anyone seen or used that acclimate container? The one that t sits in the tank and takes water from your tank adds it to the the container and sends water from the container to a bucket out of the tank? So you would temp, drip, and not let the water from the bag in. I have to find the link they are a sponsor of my local forum but I don't think they are one here.
 
I havent heard of this product yet, but would love to see a pic. Sounds pretty cool as long as its reliable with the flow control going in and out of the acclimation box.
 
Seems like a neat design, little steep on the price though. Especially with the alternative way of doing it can be done with about $2 worth of tubing and a little patience. Cool nonetheless.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new