Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Tough one. Any airborne chemicals in the area of the tank? Aerosol scents or anything like that?
Alright well your tests for nutrients are worthless. Your rock work is covered in algae, you clearly have nutrients in the system. If you didn't, then the algae would not exist; this is a far better indicator than any test. Testing won't come back positive when you have that much algae in your system. I would focus on cleaning that stuff up and monitoring your nutrients, specifically your feeding. I'm not sure if this is what's causing your SPS to die, but its definitely an issue you should address.
Those tangs break my heart.
What type of rock is that? it almost looks like concrete?
My thought is that all that green algae covering your rocks and floor is killing the SPS coral by Allelopathy(chemical warfare). Carbon would not be enough to remove the chemicals secreted by these plants if they are in decently close proximity to your corals. I also noticed your fish are too large for that size of tank. The issue of their size and the ethical implications are one thing, but just for practical purposes, those fish are too big, they need to eat too much and poop a lot. Your tank just cannot handle that size of a bioload. Here's a plan of action that I think will get you back on track. It will take some work, but not too bad.
I have taken the above steps many many times in new clients tanks that I have taken over after they have been neglected and it is definitely possible to rehab this tank and get it SPS ready if you stick with the plan. You also need to thoroughly clean your protein skimmer as in take it out, take it apart and clean everything. Take all of that junk sitting in your sump and vacuum out all the debris sitting in the bottom. If your city water is treated with chloramines, make sure to dose with Seachem Prime before adding into the tank or make sure that it is going through two carbon units in your RO/DI system.
- Get a 5 gallon bucket of your tank water, filled with 2-3 gallons of your tank water. Grab a rock out of the tank one at a time. Get a wire brush and while keeping your rocks in the water as much as possible (to preserve the life in them), scrub absolutely every last visible bit of green algae off them. Then give them a thorough rinse in the tank water inside the bucket. Return the newly cleaned rock to the tank. Repeat this process until every rock is totally clean of green algae.
- Next turn off all the pumps and powerheads, take a razor blade and scrape off all of the green algae off every surface that you can. Siphon the algae and it's debris out of the tank along with a 50% water change.
- Cut your lighting back to 4 hours a day for the next month while you are doing these steps.
- Remove all of the fish from your tank while you have the rocks out and re-home them to your local fish store for store credit or whatever you want. Just get them out of there. Start with new size appropriate (small) fish, add them after quarantining them.
- Do another 50% water change, use an actual fluidized reactor to run your carbon in. Having water passively flow around a bag of carbon may remove the discoloration of the water only, but will not really remove any organics which is what we really need it for. On that same note, all the bio media you have sitting in the plastic tupperware tray is also doing nothing for you. Water will flow over it. It also needs to be in some type of fluidized reactor to do anything.
- Whatever fish you get next don't over feed them. If you are feeding frozen food feed them a very small amount twice a day. If you are feeding only flakes or pellets, once a day.
- Stop feeding any type of liquid coral foods or feeding addititves. Period.
My thought is that all that green algae covering your rocks and floor is killing the SPS coral by Allelopathy(chemical warfare). Carbon would not be enough to remove the chemicals secreted by these plants if they are in decently close proximity to your corals. I also noticed your fish are too large for that size of tank. The issue of their size and the ethical implications are one thing, but just for practical purposes, those fish are too big, they need to eat too much and poop a lot. Your tank just cannot handle that size of a bioload. Here's a plan of action that I think will get you back on track. It will take some work, but not too bad.
I have taken the above steps many many times in new clients tanks that I have taken over after they have been neglected and it is definitely possible to rehab this tank and get it SPS ready if you stick with the plan. You also need to thoroughly clean your protein skimmer as in take it out, take it apart and clean everything. Take all of that junk sitting in your sump and vacuum out all the debris sitting in the bottom. If your city water is treated with chloramines, make sure to dose with Seachem Prime before adding into the tank or make sure that it is going through two carbon units in your RO/DI system.
- Get a 5 gallon bucket of your tank water, filled with 2-3 gallons of your tank water. Grab a rock out of the tank one at a time. Get a wire brush and while keeping your rocks in the water as much as possible (to preserve the life in them), scrub absolutely every last visible bit of green algae off them. Then give them a thorough rinse in the tank water inside the bucket. Return the newly cleaned rock to the tank. Repeat this process until every rock is totally clean of green algae.
- Next turn off all the pumps and powerheads, take a razor blade and scrape off all of the green algae off every surface that you can inside the aquarium. Siphon the algae and it's debris out of the tank along with a 50% water change.
- Cut your lighting back to 4 hours a day for the next month while you are doing these steps.
- Remove all of the fish from your tank while you have the rocks out and re-home them to your local fish store for store credit or whatever you want. Just get them out of there. Start with new size appropriate (small) fish, add them after quarantining them.
- Do another 50% water change, use an actual fluidized reactor to run your carbon in. Having water passively flow around a bag of carbon may remove the discoloration of the water only, but will not really remove any organics which is what we really need it for. On that same note, all the bio media you have sitting in the plastic tupperware tray is also doing nothing for you. Water will flow over it. It also needs to be in some type of fluidized reactor to do anything.
- Whatever fish you get next don't over feed them. If you are feeding frozen food feed them a very small amount twice a day. If you are feeding only flakes or pellets, once a day.
- Stop feeding any type of liquid coral foods or feeding addititves. Period.
Accusations of animal cruelty is a bit harsh. Let's focus on helping the OP with his current issues. He's already stated he's looking for a good home which means he actually cares for his animals. To the OP, you've got a lot of great advice and I'm confident you'll succeed in your goals with the right help and encouragement.Those tangs are almost fully grown and that is pretty cruel to keep them in a 50 cube. Start with trading them into a local fish store ASAP. You'll no longer be committing animal cruelty and you'll cut your nutrients down.
This is like you living your life out of a closet.
My thought is that all that green algae covering your rocks and floor is killing the SPS coral by Allelopathy(chemical warfare). Carbon would not be enough to remove the chemicals secreted by these plants if they are in decently close proximity to your corals. I also noticed your fish are too large for that size of tank. The issue of their size and the ethical implications are one thing, but just for practical purposes, those fish are too big, they need to eat too much and poop a lot. Your tank just cannot handle that size of a bioload. Here's a plan of action that I think will get you back on track. It will take some work, but not too bad.
I have taken the above steps many many times in new clients tanks that I have taken over after they have been neglected and it is definitely possible to rehab this tank and get it SPS ready if you stick with the plan. You also need to thoroughly clean your protein skimmer as in take it out, take it apart and clean everything. Take all of that junk sitting in your sump and vacuum out all the debris sitting in the bottom. If your city water is treated with chloramines, make sure to dose with Seachem Prime before adding into the tank or make sure that it is going through two carbon units in your RO/DI system.
- Get a 5 gallon bucket of your tank water, filled with 2-3 gallons of your tank water. Grab a rock out of the tank one at a time. Get a wire brush and while keeping your rocks in the water as much as possible (to preserve the life in them), scrub absolutely every last visible bit of green algae off them. Then give them a thorough rinse in the tank water inside the bucket. Return the newly cleaned rock to the tank. Repeat this process until every rock is totally clean of green algae.
- Next turn off all the pumps and powerheads, take a razor blade and scrape off all of the green algae off every surface that you can inside the aquarium. Siphon the algae and it's debris out of the tank along with a 50% water change.
- Cut your lighting back to 4 hours a day for the next month while you are doing these steps.
- Remove all of the fish from your tank while you have the rocks out and re-home them to your local fish store for store credit or whatever you want. Just get them out of there. Start with new size appropriate (small) fish, add them after quarantining them.
- Do another 50% water change, use an actual fluidized reactor to run your carbon in. Having water passively flow around a bag of carbon may remove the discoloration of the water only, but will not really remove any organics which is what we really need it for. On that same note, all the bio media you have sitting in the plastic tupperware tray is also doing nothing for you. Water will flow over it. It also needs to be in some type of fluidized reactor to do anything.
- Whatever fish you get next don't over feed them. If you are feeding frozen food feed them a very small amount twice a day. If you are feeding only flakes or pellets, once a day.
- Stop feeding any type of liquid coral foods or feeding addititves. Period.