You have a bad opinion of me because you have an agenda regarding prophylactic QT. In your article review you put words in your Vet's mouth that, if true, could cost him his license. I highly doubt he is an open supporter of unsupervised use of antibiotics.I have to start this comment by saying that I probably have a bad opinion of you because of your dismissive response to my comment on the article, but anyone can scroll back and see that you are being dishonest about what was said and you should apologize and stop arguing dishonestly.
Here’s actual quotes:
“Glucan isn’t new. It’s been studied. It’s not beneficial for most fish in our aquariums.”
“While there have been some positive effects found, there are also studies that found no effect at all. Promoting this as some magic cure all is pretty much insane. It MAY be helpful in SOME instances.”
I think there is an effort to change that. My understanding is that chelated copper products will be available again when they are re-marketed to not be fish medications. The biggest issue I'm aware of is that since they are all imported it has to go through an import approval process. Not sure if the suppliers will find that paperwork worthwhile.
They do still have H2O2 available there.
I don't understand why anyone would have an "agenda" for quarantining. Prophylactic or passive observation. I hate quarantining. It's just a neccessary evil in my mind. I would love to kick back, enjoy my DT, and when I see a fish for sale that I like just drop it on in. But my experiences tell me that probably won't end well. OK, maybe just watch the fish in QT for a month and then put it in. Wait... I travel, go to work, have a house to maintain, cook/clean/raise kids, go to the beach, watch football on Sundays and my wife seems to have all other free time planned out already... I don't really have time to stare at fish in QT all day. What feasible option(s) do I have left??!You have a bad opinion of me because you have an agenda regarding prophylactic QT.
I disagree. Just like a marathon runner - who is healthy that gets a scratch - and dies of streptococcal sepsis. I think you are a bit wrong hereI would say a healthy fish is one that can live in it's natural environment and survive it's challenges.
I have healthy dogs. If one gets a tick on him he doesn't suddenly become unhealthy.
You are probably right. I do have a bad opinion of you. Mostly from the way you conduct yourself online and it goes beyond just what you said in that one quote.You have a bad opinion of me because you have an agenda regarding prophylactic QT. In your article review you put words in your Vet's mouth that, if true, could cost him his license. I highly doubt he is an open supporter of unsupervised use of antibiotics.
Now if you want to prove the statements in my article are false, by all means do so. Just be prepared to do so using scientific references and not "my vet said".
If you had kept reading, I did correct myself on miss quoting him. His comment is still seemingly incorrect. He hasn't any offered any scientific support for his position. If he is going to claim a scientific study is wrong I don't think it is too much to ask for a scientific study that disproves it.
I guess that means all the fish in our aquariums are NOT HEALTHY, unless you think that a glass box sitting inside a house with electric lights over it is “natural”.
I hope you don't think of your tank as a true natural environment. It's an artificial environment. Even the largest public aquariums cannot duplicate the biodiversity and more importantly dilution that the ocean affords.
I'm ok and can respect that. I can appreciate people who have differing opinions from mine. Not everyone can do that.You are probably right. I do have a bad opinion of you. Mostly from the way you conduct yourself online and it goes beyond just what you said in that one quote.
Thats why he is able to respond - to explain what he meant or?I dont think VWNed meant "the wild" I think he meant environment as in current surroundings (aquarium life) and the ability to adapt to the challenges posed by captive life for a fish.
That's the way I took it at least